I dont mind anyone disagreeing just my opinion. 1. Ward 2. Kovalev 3. Lomachenko 4. Crawford 5. GGG 6. Canelo 7. Inoue 8. Thurman 9. Uysk 10. Joshua Mentions - M Garcia, Spence, Linares, Pacquiao, R Gonzalez.
Your list a great! I don't understand how a mayweather return prompt so many p4p thread. But I see yours doesn't have him on the list, good choice or else it will go down the same path as the others. But there is a legitimate super fight this weekend that can change the landscape. Maybe we should at least wait for that.
I agree mayweather returning doesn't earn him a list on the p4p list. Imo to be on the p4p list u need to be good and have a good resume. There are the few exceptions like lomachenko who may not have the resume but tremendous skill
Nice list, some of your bottom 4 are interchangeable with you honourable mention. Otherwise I mostly agree
Maybe I'm misreading your post, but are you insinuating Floyd isn't good or has a good resume? He's been inactive and thats the only reason he should be left off a P4P list. He's better than ALL of those fighters on the list and has a MUCH better resume than any of them. He whitewashed the # 6 rated guy on the list by at least 7 or 8 rounds. Inactivity/"psuedo-retirement" is the only reason he's left off. He's an elite ATG and clearly beat the other ATG of his generation. Also, Pacman should be much higher IMO. He steamrolled through Bradley and beat a game Vargas after losing to Floyd. In fact, aside from getting KO'd in a fight it looked like he was about to KO Marquez, the guy hadn't lost officially since the Morales fight years ago. I'll chalk it up to poor wording on your part.
Excellent list. Blows the other two lists we've seen out of the water. Just switch Kovalev and Ward and you've got the same list as me.
I've left him of because he's been retired and fighting McGregor doesn't earn him a place. He hasn't done anything recently like the others to earn a place
The top 7 are all probably locks. Add Roman, Pacquiao, and Ioka on board and that sounds like I vibe.
Ioka? Yeah he's good, but when someone mentions a name like that about top 10 p4p my first thought without even seeing a list is... that guy can't rate Rigondeaux higly enough.
