Both were big punchers, but Satterfield was ~180 pounds. Could he land the big one and put Foreman out or is Satterfield doomed?
Satterfield is doomed. He would not be a cruiser bouncing shells off a battleship, more an ocean liner with 15'' guns trying to win a fight with a battleship.
Good analsis compadre ^ ( i.e. The British BShip Hood had very little deck armor in its battle with the Bismark and we know how that turned out)