ATG Ranking: Khan or Walters

Amir has better wins

 

I'd give Khan the edge based on greater depth to his resume.

Now that we've got that one out of the way, time for the real question - better ATG ranking, Massimiliano "Momo" Duran or Hector Acero Sanchez??

 

Khan, clearly.

A nothing thread.

 

Neither of them are ATGs

 

Neither aren't anywhere near ATGS. But Walters has only lost once and to a future all time great. Plus Walters' win over Donaire trumps anything Khan has done by far.

 

A prime Maidana says otherwise, as does Malingaggi, Kotelnik and Algeri

 

Only Loma fans even know who Walters is

 

'Prime Maidana haha no chance that was the same one that lost every single round to Devon Alexander, had a close fight with a shot, old retired fat Erik Morales, and lost to the very average Kotelnik. It wasn't Maidanas prime at all, that was a pre Robert Garcia trained green Maidana, he was a massively improved fighter by the Mayweather and Broner fights - that was his prime years. And Khan barely won that fight, he ran all night and should really have been stopped.

Donaire was top 3 P4P, Donaire as been a multi weight world champ, and will likely get into the HOF. Donaire was on a whole another level to Maidana.

Malignaggi, Kotelnik ( a guy who lost to Mbaye and Witter), and Algieri are not strong wins at all in any way! all feather fisted, all easily forgotten about average fighters at best, that's like a list of the weakest world champions of recent times.

 

Past his best, out of his best weight Nonito is nowhere near as impressive as you make out.

I’d put pre-Garcia Maidana above that.

Walters’ best wins are two former flyweight champs.

 

Horrendous analytical ability. Have a block.