Are you proud of AJ's performance ? Would you stick up for him or cut him down if having a friendly pub conversation with say a group of Italian boxing fans ? He avenged his defeat He took no damage He showed good ring movement He dominated the points card Was that enough ?
So you are in the he should have traded so Fat Andy had a chance camp?? Wasn't a very good sport old chap was he...
You have to credit him for taking the immediate rematch on neutral ground and dominating his opponent. It's not really the place of a fan to be "proud" of him, that's for his parents, trainer etc.