SOme say so, but also some say James should have won the 1st and not a draw. I saw both as two master painters on the canvas of boxing blessing us with 2 high IQ fighters/artists of the ring.
Side note-I saw that fight similar to Mosley vs Cotto. I thought it was a great fight-that I had Mosley winning, but like McCallum-Toney both fights showed what happens when 2 high quality fighters meet up.