Bob Velin (USA Today) – [url]115-112 Pacquiao[/url] Nick Tylwalk (FanSided) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Steve Bunce (BoxNation) – [url]115-113 Horn[/url] Mike Sloan (Sherdog) – [url]116-111 Pacquiao[/url] Gary Randall (Sherdog) – [url]116-112 Horn[/url] Mike Fridley (Sherdog) – [url]115-112 Horn[/url] Gary Parrish (CBS Sports) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Brian Campbell (CBS Sports) – [url]114-114[/url] Jason McIntyre (Fox Sports 1) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Dieter Kurtenbach (Fox Sports) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Josh Katzowitz (Forbes) – [url]115-112 Pacquiao[/url] Brian Mazique (Forbes) – [url]114-114 Draw[/url] Fraser Coffeen (Bloody Elbow) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Anton Tabuena (Bloody Elbow) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Bad Left Hook – [url]116-111 and 115-113 Pacquiao[/url] Mike Coppinger (Ring Magazine) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Michael Rosenthal (Ring Magazine) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Ryan Songalia (Ring Magazine and Rappler) – [url]117-110 Pacquiao[/url] Doug Fischer (Ring Magazine) – [url]116-112 or 115-113 Pacquiao[/url] Tom Gray (Ring Magazine) – [url]“Had Horn wide mate.”[/url] Mike Baca II (Ring Magazine and Undisputed Champion Network) – [url]“I’ve already rewatched. 115-113 Pac was the lowest I could go…”[/url] Steve Kim (Undisputed Champion Network) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Lance Pugmire (LA Times) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Boxing News – [url]115-113 Pacquiao (Verdict: Close fight, no robbery)[/url] Michael Wilbon (ESPN) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Dan Rafael (ESPN) – [url]117-111 Pacquiao[/url] Marcellus Wiley (ESPN) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Ramona Shelburne (ESPN) – [url]Pacquiao [/url] Nigel Collins (ESPN) – [url]114-113 Pacquiao (“Disagree w/ the “robbery” talk.”)[/url] Stephen A. Smith (ESPN) – Pacquiao robbed!!!! Teddy Atlas (ESPN) – 116-111 Pacquiao Arash markazi (ESPN) – [url]Pacquiao won[/url] T.J. Quinn (ESPN) – [url]Pacquiao won (“This is a hometown hit job. Manny looked old, but mostly in control.”)[/url] Salvador Rodriguez (ESPN) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Greg Bishop (Sports Illustrated) – [url]117-111 Pacquiao[/url] Al Bernstein (Showtime Sports) – [url]“I could see a draw or close for Pac”[/url] Chris Mannix (Yahoo! Sports) – [url]Pacquiao won[/url] Kevin Iole (Yahoo! Sports) – [url]115-113 for Pacquiao[/url] Gareth A. Davies (The Telegraph) – [url]115-113 Pacquiao[/url] Jay Cowan (Spike Sports) – [url]115-112 Pacquiao[/url] Marcos Villegas (Fight Hub TV) – [url]“I had him (Pacquiao) up by one point.”[/url] Jonathan Snowden (Bleacher Report) – [url]“I had Manny Pacquiao in a close fight.”[/url] ******* – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Ryan Phillips (The Big Lead) – [url]116-111 Pacquiao[/url] Lennox Lewis – [url]Pacquiao won[/url] Lou DiBella (promoter) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] DJ Gallo (The Guardian) – [url]117-111 pacquiao[/url] Ben Thompson (Fight Hype) – [url]115-112 Pacquiao[/url] Jeff Powell (The Daily Mail) – [url]Pacquiao robbed[/url] Bob Sheridan (commentator) – 114-114 Paulie Malignaggi – [url]“I had horn by a point…”[/url] Eric Raskin (Former writer for ESPN and Grantland) – [url]114-114[/url] Graham Houston (Boxing Monthly) – [url]114-114 (“Cd. have gone either way.”)[/url] Martin Chesnutt (Boxing Monthly) – [url]115-112 Pacquiao (“…but was comfortable with 115-113 either way.”)[/url] Andrew Harrison (Boxing Monthly) – [url]116-113 Horn[/url] Adam Abramowitz (Saturday Night Boxing and Transnational Boxing Rankings board member) – [url]116-111 Pacquiao[/url] Rafael G (The Fight City) – [url]“Pacquiao won by 2 or 3 points.”[/url] Lee Wylie (The Fight City) – [url]Pacquiao won (“…certainly not a robbery. Close fight.”)[/url] Patrick Connor (BWAA/IBRO member) – [url]Pacquiao won[/url] Michael Montero (Montero On Boxing) – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Behind the Gloves – [url]117-110 Pacquiao[/url] Erik Morales – [url]Pacquiao robbed[/url] Juan Manuel Marquez – [url]116-112 Pacquiao[/url] Timothy Bradley – Pacquiao won (very close fight) Guillermo Rigondeaux – [url]Pacquiao won[/url] 55 for Pacquiao, 7 for Horn, 5 draw
Again more excuses. Go back down to Australia and avenge the loss. You keep talking about rematching pbf when pac has jeff horn problems. Pac got his ass kicked beat up and roughed up by a c level fighter.
This content is protected Dude, are you mentally ill? What excuse(s) have I made? Pointing out FACTS? The OVERWHELMING majority of media, fans, and fighters had Pac winning and getting robbed. I agree that Pac got roughed up — not by punches, but by excessive illegal tactics like headbutts, headlocks, shoving, leaning, and clinching.
I saw the fight pac got his ass kicked and is running from the rematch. He's talking about other fights when he has unfinished business with horn. Im tired of the excuses an unavenged loss to a c level fighter who's still active looks bad no other way to spin it.
maidana was just as dirty against Floyd in the first fight. Floyd found a way to win. Then rematched maidana to rubber stamp it. also maidana is better than horn
ODLH was definitely further diminished however, Floyd narrowly squeaked out a win, while Pacquiao obliterated ODLH. Yeah Pacs win was far more decisive and impressive. Old man Whitaker looked better against a pime De La Hoya than FMJ did against the our of prime ODLH.
Floyd fought 3 of those same guys. Two of them before 18 months before Pac did. Each one is arguably a better victory for Floyd than it was for Pac, without question the Oscar win. Corrales 2001 and Genaro 1998 are almost certainly superior to all those you have listed except for Barrera and Morales. Beating Jose Luis Castillo, regarded as the best LW of the 2000-10 decade, for the lineal at LW, is once again better than anything you have listed except for Barrera and Morales. Floyd beating bloated Marquez two years before Pac/Marquez III is the most hated and dismissed major victory in recent times but I'll put that above Pac's Oscar win. Floyd's 147 Mosley win is better than Pac's 147 win over Oscar for sure. Floyd's wins over Canelo and Pacquiao himself are greater than any of those listed, hands down. If you made a list of their combined best victories, Floyd represents.
I thought Maidana was dirtier. A knee lunge, a spear, rabbit punches, and the countless low blows... Horn just did a pseudo-Wladimir-ish using of body mass and mangling hands/arms. Nobody knew who Jeff Horn was. Not an exaggeration as there were a lot of hardcores who had never once read his name.
didn’t hear much complaints about how maidana fought either. In fact folks were loving it both are atgs but they are held to such different standards it’s ridiculous
Interesting thread. It's always entertaining watching pakkuman and pimp c go at it. It never gets old. As far as who had the better wins I agree with the reasoning behind Paquiao.
Nothing in that posts is about Canelo drama girl. Why don't you make that thread? Are you so damn insecure you can't have threads on other fighters?? Cry about a canelo thread or doing it yourself baby..... jeez..
Manny has some great wins, but you’re not being objective. Oscar was finished and drained. That’s not one of Manny’s best wins. Marg should be on your list. The size disparity was huge.
