Keith Thurman vs these top fighters

Beats Judah(glass), Alexander(shite), Mayorga(toss up), Malignaggi(too small),Algieri(not good enough) and Clottey(good just not as good as keef).

Cotto and Margarito without the plaster beat him in absolute slugfests.

Outclassed vs the rest

 

Oscar: Win idk how
Mosley: Win idk how
Cotto: Ko win
Judah: Ko win
Clottey: Ko win
Malinaggi: Ko win
Mayorga: Ko win
Margarito: Loses
Mayweather: Loses
Pacquiao:
Maidana: Ko win
Bradley: Loses
Algeri: Ko win
Spence: Loses
Crawford: Ko win

Im a big Thurman fan btw

 

Loses to most. Beats Algieri, and, maybe Malignaggi. Hell, a prime Thurman lost to a shell of Manny.

 

Beating Cotto,Mosley and Oscar lmao. But he loses to Errol'need for speed'Spence. That is funny.

 

Spence isn’t good because he got in a car crash? Also I’m confident he beats cotto. Mosley and Oscar are toss ups but I’m bias because I don’t really like them and I’m a Thurman fan

 

That wasn’t prime Thurman, that was a Thurman coming off multiple injuries and layoffs. I mean I still think a prime Thurman would get knocked out by prime pac but let’s be honest here

 

He loses to prime Oscar and Mosley via ud. I see him as a level below.
I think him and cotto are a toss up. Gun to my head i'd pick cotto
He definitely judahs judah
I think he'd edge clottey but it would be disputed
Destroys paulie
Mayorga is better than people remember. He beat forest. Prime mayorga might beat him if he draws him into a war.
Loses to may and pac via ud
I think he'd beat maidana, just not sure how
I feel he's a bad match-up for Bradley. I think he wins a decision here.
He obviously beats algeri
I think he loses to spence and crawford, most likely by decision. Who knows though

Just my opinion. I'm not the biggest Thurman fan. In fact , I dont care for him much

 

De La Hoya: L KO
Mosley: L UD
Cotto: L UD
Judah: W UD
Clottey: W UD
Malignaggi: W KO
Mayorga: W UD
Margarito: W UD
Pacquiao: L KO (in his prime)
Maidana: W UD
Bradley: L SD
Alexander: W UD
Algeri: W KO
Spence: L UD
Crawford: L KO

 

You're delusional if you think Thurman goes the distance with a prime Mosley.

 

Thurman vs:
L Dela Hoya
L Mosley
L Cotto
Draw Judah. Judah from Spinks II and Floyd was pretty good.
W Clottey
W Malinaggi
L Mayorga
L Margarito
L Mayweather
L Pacquiao
Draw Maidana
L Bradley
W Alexander
W Algeri
L Spence
L Crawford

4-10-2

 

easy with the insults buddy. You disagree that's fine. I think its more likely he gets KO'd by Shane then win himself, but I saw a UD win for Shane as the most likely outcome.

 

Triggered by a hypothetical matchup? Haha

 

Showstopper97, post: 20750564, member: 123456"]How does a prime Keith 'One Time' Thurman (14-17) do vs these top fighters.

Thurman vs:
Dela Hoya—Thurman loses
Mosley—loses
Cotto—loses
Judah—Thurman wins
Clottey— wins
Malinaggi —wins
Mayorga—loses
Margarito—loses
Mayweather—lol
Pacquiao—derp
Maidana—wins
Bradley—draw
Alexander—wins
Algeri—wins
Spence—loses
Crawford—loses

6-9-1

Edit: I guess he improved