Probably a fight that could have happened it Hide hadn't been nuts. In many ways Hide was Haye before Haye. Natural cruiser with huge power, but while didnt have the natural size to compete with the big heavyweights. Also careers beset with big gaps for injuries and outside ring things.
Either Haye gets to Hide early, or Hide Carl Thompson's him. 75/25 in favour of Haye, Hide was a well respected fighter but Haye could really turn it up, that KO against Chisora at HW has aged well.
Haye was too big and fluid for Hide, Herbie used to move too much and just fought in spurts, Haye took Wlad`s power better than Hide took Vitali and Bowe`s power.
Have to go with Haye although a Hide upset wouldn't be out of the question. Hide was just too chinny to pick here.