Evander Holyfield vs these 70s HW's

Holyfield beats them all apart from Ali, Holmes and maybe start of the 70s Frazier as well.

 

Ali
Frazier
Holmes
Norton beat him
Lyle and Quarry are 50/50
Beats the rest

 

He losses to Ali, Frazier, Foreman, and Holmes. He splits a few w the likes of Quarry, Bonavena and beats everyone else. Of course he would put up solid efforts in all.

 

Ali UD. But it has to be the pre parkinson desease one.
Frazier UD. Again it has to be FOTC frazier.
Holmes UD.
Foreman 7th or 6th TKO after forcing holyfield to fight inside and make it a slugfest.
Either Norton by SD or Holyfield by SD, close fight anyway.
Holyfield beat Lyle by decision, i don't even think Ron has Foreman's ability to cut he ring off to force Holyfield to fight an inside war. So i believe the real deal outbox him and sometimes he outslug him, but with Lyle's greater strength and power holyfield is forced to revert back to boxing and pulls out a clear decision win.
He beats stops quarry on cuts in a brutal slugfest and outpoints Bonavena by a hard fought decision and keeps young on the defensive and outpoints him too in a close fight. He beats the rest by TKO or UD with no real difficulty.

 

I'm going to say he has at least 6 losses, if he got wobbled against a Lyle or Shavers like he did against Bert Cooper he wouldn't survive.

 

70s HW's
Ali Ali wins this by jabbing holys nut off
Frazier 55/45 to Frazier. Joe is slightly more relentless
Foreman Evander wins this by late stoppage
Norton close close fight. Holyfield is slightly better
Holmes comfortable win for Larry. Stops him late

Holyfield wins against against all these. Not easy
Lyle
Shavers
Quarry
Bonavena
Ellis
Young
Wepner
Cobb
Coetzee
Tate
Weaver

 

Great list! Imagine how amazing most of those fights would be...

 

Here my most likely Scenarios:

Ali : Depends on which Ali
Frazier : 60/40 Holyfield
Foreman : 40/60 Foreman
Norton : 50/50 probably a SD
Holmes : 40/60 for Holmes
Lyle : Holyfield UD / TKO
Shavers : Holyfield TKO / KO
Quarry : Holyfield TKO
Bonavena : Holyfield TKO / UD
Ellis : Holyfield KO
Young : Holyfield TKO
Wepner : Holyfield TKO
Cobb : Holyfield TKO
Coetzee : Holyfield UD
Tate : Holyfield UD
Weaver : Holyfield SD

 

I think he would beat most versions of 70s Ali

 

Beats all but Ali, Foreman, Frazier and Holmes.

 

Looses to Ali, Frazier, Holmes, all by decision.

Beats the rest

 

I mostly agree with this. Jimmy Young might have spoiled his way to a close indecisive points win.

 

Foreman stopping him is a very real possibility given that Holyfield did somewhat struggle with a past it Foreman but i slightly favor that he'd weather the storm and KO Foreman late

 

Holyfield could beat anyone from the 70s on tte right night. It's not like any fighter from that era had to fight peak versions of all the best guys.