Ugas is too one dimensional and doesn't have the power to deter Taylor, who I think worst case scenario just takes the fight to him inside if he has problems boxing at range.
Most probably Ugas. Josh taylor is an amazing boxer and if there was a stoppage I would most likely favour him but Ugas jab and pressure and size should prevail to a close but clear decision. I also rate beating a 42 year old pacquiao ahead of beating Ramirez.
Taylor is as tall as Ugas. Taylor looks like a dried raisin on the scales, I don't think he has an easy time making 140.
But I'm not just basing it off him bashing up Porter and Ugas in the gym when he was a mere seven fight novice, I simply think Taylor's the better fighter and Ugas has already lost to three fighters Taylor would've beat on his pro debut and I also watched Ugas go life and death against Levan Ghvamichava too.