I’d give it to Lamotta. Felix loved to come forward and as powerful as his vaunted left hook was I don’t see him grinding down Jake. On the other hand Lamotta was a straight forward brawling man beast. I could easily see him brawling with Felix and breaking him down. He handed the great Sugar Ray Robinson his first loss this way.
LaMotta would maul him. Jake would take some damage on the way in but so what? It would get rough. Trinidad was lethal at midrange but I see The Bronx Bull being in his chest all nite. Maybe a stoppage. Certainly a LaMotta victory.
Jake didn't have the power to earn a guy like Tito's respect. Tito would walk him straight down and tee off on that chin till it was all over. I see this going like the William Joppy fight
I love Trinidad but he cant compete at world class at middleweight LaMotta was a bull and would beat Tito up bad.
The old classic of an Orthodox vs a Southpaw. Equal amount of heart and grit..I say it ends with a finish for Jake in the late rounds.
Trinidad was better skilled. But he didn't have the greatest chin, and didn't like to be crowded, and as he went up in weight, became less effective. Lamotta didn't have the skill level of Trinidad, but was a natural middleweight, had a great chin, a tank in human form but was slicker defensively than given credit for. Watch his fights closely. He slips and rides punches expertly,(He was NOT Ricardo Mayorga, who took a lot of punches cleanly) This fight would be a tell of two half's. The 1st half would be Trinidad being busier, keeping Lomatta at bay with his movement and combo punching. Winning rds. The 2nd half would be Lamotta cutting the distance, and crowding Trinidad. Forcing him to the ropes, working him inside, and keeping Trinidad from getting maximum leverage on his punches. This is where Lamotta eventually grinds Trinidad down and stopping him, especially if the fight is for 15rds.