Who really won Floyd Mayweather vs Jose Luis Castillo 1

Ricky Fatton - The beginning of the end.
Marquez - Flogged the living daylights out of him. After almost 2 years colling his heels.
Judah - destroyed
Mosely - Mauled. Battered. Bruised. Beat.
Canelo - lol. Canelololol
Ortiz - Good Night. Got a dose of his own medicine.
Cotto - lost by 4rounds.
Maidana - Put up the best performance in Fight 1. Looked like Floyd was gone. Down 5 rounds to zip. One eye closed. Yet won the next 7 rounds putting on a boxing master class.
Gurreiro - Who?
Pacman - Finally shut everyone up.
Berto - Should have stayed Ernie's side kick a little longer and stayed in Sesame Street.

 

Castle won.

 

Castillo whooped that ass and got robbed in Vegas what a surprise

 

Technically speaking he was dropped once versus Carlos Hernandez I think? He hurt his hand and went down and they counted it as a knockdown, but it was basically a technicality only.

 

The only fight you can argue Floyd lost.

 

FLOYD MAYWEATHER TEACHES HOW TO THROW INSIDE SHOTS WITH PROPER TECHNIQUE; REVEALS COMMON MISTAKE - YouTube

 

Had Mayweather squeaking by but it really is an either way fight. Mayweather’s only one at that. The first Maidana fight you really have to scramble around to get a draw, Castillo fight there’s easily 7/8 rounds for Castillo if you wanted.

 

Castillo won that fight, period. However, as we all know, when the boxing powers want a certain fighter to win, they will make it happen. No surprise there.

 

Got dropped against Judah legitimately but that was ruled a slip

 

Correct scorecard.

 

Castillo won the fight by 2 points on my card, maybe 3 as there was a round I think could easily have gone to him but I can see going either way. He was the effective aggressor, repeatedly putting him to the ropes and hammering Mayweather's body. Mayweather was mostly flash, did land some good shots here and there but in a fair, unbiased atmosphere not controlled by promoters he gets the win.

 

I also had the Mexican Castle win the second fight too but no one agrees with me and I dont want to make a thread about it. Im amazed at Mayweather's 50-0 record and think he is top 15 of all time, that's also why I don't make a fuss about it.

 

I've still never seen both. Many agree he lost the first fight.

 

I scored it for Castillo. I remember my scorecard was identical to Harold Lederman's.

 

JLC won that fight mate he got hosed on the cards. Vegas is worse than Queensland