No. He was not defensively great and it was only a matter if time till someone got to him. Ruddock never landed anything because Lewis brilliantly caught him first. Lewis fought a perfect fight so never got caught vs Tua. But he always had a weakness vs lesser fighters as Briggs caught him and only the ropes held him up. So he always had a tendency to get caught vs lesser fighters.
In a sense, no, those guys won on their merits and he lost on his relatively small amount of weakness. But in another sense, he could match those guys 10 more times and plausibly win all ten decisively. So, in another sense, still no, but I understand why this is a question.
I'm a big Lewis fan, but no. They won because they made the most of their opportunities. Lewis showed in the rematches that he was capable of beating both McCall and Rahman. The fact he did not the first time around was because he took them both lightly. That is Lewis's fault, not theirs. He was a great fighter (top 5 heavyweight ATG for me) but complacency was one of his flaws.
Nope, he just got caught cold it happens. But Lennox did prove he was the better fighter by winning the rematches very convincingly. He's beaten every fighter he's ever stepped in the ring with, just wish he would have fought Vitali again.
I think the McCall fight was a bad stoppage. Do I think Lewis would have recovered and went on to win? My opinion, no. Do I think you should give a fighter the chance to see if he can when he beats the counts. Yes. Rahman fight not a fluke in any way. Rahman threw a big punch, and Lewis did not time his defense correctly. He got knocked out.
Only special fighters can get up from devastating KO inducing punches at HW Ali Holmes Fury Lennox got tougher with age which applies to lots of heavies. Took bombs off Vitali.
I don't think fluke is the correct term. Boxers are supposed to hit their opponent, they did and Lewis could not get up. Do I believe Lewis lost focus, yes. Did he pay the consequences, yes.
Not flukes, but very unlikely to ever happen again Lewis does beat either guy 99 out of 100, but they earned their wins with good punches, especially that right hand from Rahman