Shields has never held four titles at the same time. In fact, she has never held the WBA. BoxRec: Claressa Shields Her reputation as a 3x undisputed champion is totally fake. She is a 0x undisputed champion
Unpopular take but I think holding 3 of the 4 major belts should count for something, everybody who became undisputed before the 2000's only captured 3 titles so yeah I that it should be taken into account somehow.
Shields can claim to be whatever she likes because at the end of the day she is just a big fish in a small pond. Once she retires she will likely be forgotten about within a couple of years.
When it's all said and done Katie Taylor will be remembered and held in a higher regard than the self proclaimed GWOAT.
I think Shields will be. She doesn´t have a memorable fight or any rivalries. Nor is she that popular. It´s beyond me why Shields has not been on a single PPC PPV. Claressa is talented, and she cam up in the right time, unfortunately for her she is simply too big physically. The divisions she fights in have barely any competition. Shields just won the WBO heavyweight belt. Well, the WBO had previously only sanctioned two fights at that weight, both in 2019. The other belt was the WBC, which has sanctioned only 8 fights at the weight. The whole division has just 24 active boxers listed on boxrec, 8 of whom have never won a fight. 1 is 2-2 and 3 others have lost more fights than they have won. So that leaves 12 active boxers who have more wins than losses. Super middle, middle and jr-middle are similar stories. Quite a few belts that Shields won, had never been contested for before. The organizations made their belts available just for her. Which Shields does kinda deserve credit for, but just shows how weak the divisions are. Meanwhile lightweight alone has roughly 200 active boxers, which is more than the combined sum of every division Shields has fought in.
That's not true! When it comes to being the most egotistical, abrasive, repellent, delusional, obnoxious, despicable, cringeworthy, loudmouthed, annoying, painfully idiotic, vomitus female boxer in the sport, who's devoid of any semblance of self awareness. She's undisputed in every division she's set foot in.