Did Randall have his number or Chavez lost simply because he was outta his prime?

I'm pretty sure most fans pick the mythological "prime" Tyson to defeat Douglas had they fought before, is this the same for Chavez?
Let's suppose Chavez reverts to his prime in order to face Randall, what's the result? Is this another case of a fighter ruining his prime by losing his discipline or Randall simply had the right tools and gameplan to beat any version?

 

I'm of the opinion Chavez was just past it. Hard style of fighting to maintain when your past it.

 

I think Randall had the style and the confidence to always trouble Chavez tbh.

 

I’m undecided. A part of me thinks that the Chavez of three years earlier does a bit better but I can’t guarantee that

 

Frankie always said he could beat Chavez, at the time myself and some others were a little dubious when he said it. When I saw him again some time later with the belt I told him ,,ya made a believer outta me.

 

Julio was 90 fights into his career, had become pampered and was partying.

Prime Julio stops Frankie in 7 rounds of overwhelming offense.

 

Both things.
Chavez was past prime and Randall had his number.

 

Maybe at 135 pounds, anything over that and I'll take Frankie.

 

Good one!