You keep bringing up British heavyweights going through "tough" competition compared to other countries. I don't see the point of this thread. Are you trying to say they should have it easier ? The best of the best benefit from tough matchmaking, it's better for the fans and filters out the Lot. Any fighter that gets carefully matched always gets exposed eventually. Frazer Clarke would've got smashed anyway, he's a slow stiff
Then you have completely misunderstood the thread I'm not saying anyone should have it easier or harder but asking if it benefits everyone Let's give an example so you may understand it better if I haven't explained what I was questioning well enough So... David Price is a big punching HW no one is disputing that Deontay Wilder is a big punching HW no one is disputing that Now look at how differently they were matched They turned pro within 6 months of each other Price his 14th fight was against Harrison which he won in a round In Wilders 28th fight he fought the same Harrison after Price In Prices 16th fight he was facing Thompson In Wilders 16th fight he wasn't facing anyone at that same level Now what the thread was asking but based on the scale of the British title was (I knowthe Thompson fight wasn't for the British title but was trying to give an easy example as i think you still misunderstood with what you wrote re Clarke) is it better to be matched tough early on in big draining tough fights just to break out of the domestic scene or better to have lots of less taxing learning bouts and be fresh for a potential title shot Some losses can completely change a career trajectory Does that make more sense now?
The Americans claim all their best heavyweight athletes chose other sports such as Basketball, Ice Hockey or American Rugby. They think LeBron James would dominate boxing? He would get battered by John McDermott. The British Heavyweight scene is clearly levels above other heavyweight scenes. And this argument that their heavyweights chose other sports over boxing can be made in Britain also. Just imagine Emile Heskey trained by Robert McCracken, or Duncan Ferguson trained by the McGuigans, or Freddie Flintoff trained by Adam Booth. British heavyweight athletes are in class of their own. And now Britain has a young Heavyweight in Tom Aspinall making major waves in the MMA world. The biggest domestic fight the Americans could put together in the last 10 years was Wilder vs Dominic Brezeale. While Fabio Wardley vs David Adeleye was a greater level fight than that. And Wardley vs Adeleye wasn't even the biggest All British domestic match up. There is still:- Whyte vs Chisora Chisora vs Joyce Joyce vs Dubois Dubious vs Joshua Joshua vs Whyte Whyte vs Fury Fury vs Chisora The British scene produced all those great match ups, and many more while the best the Americans had to offer was Wilder vs Brezeale. Levels.
Yes, multiple people including me have already said it benefits the fighter, especially when said competition is just high domestic level. Rough match making is better in the grand scheme. Price would've been smashed eventually, and it would've been before he hit world level. I don't see anyone outside of Povetkin on his resume that would have beaten Wilder besides Povetkin/Chisora and that was at the end. Even someone like Stiverne is better than Clarke
Here's a great example. Anderson just took a big step up against Bakole who smoked Yoka. Anderson lost, and we'll get to see how that Bakole fight makes or breaks Anderson. I think he's going to learn from that fight, improve his mistakes, use more footwork and come back stronger like Dubois
Jared Anderson started crying on camera which probably made other fighters look at him as a crybaby. This content is protected Bakole who is from the tough jungles of Africa where such crying is not respected. The same Bakole who relocated to Scotland, Britain, where such crying is not tolerated, probably saw Jared Anderson's crying and thought what any other British man would think:.... what a crybaby. Now crying is ok if it is kept between man and God. Or if an accomplished veteran sheds a few manly tears for the beatings he has dished out. Deontay Wilder earnt this right as he had inflicted enough pain to warrant such tears. But even his tears were laughed at by the people of Africa, Eurasia and Britain. Jared Anderson on the other hand, as a professional heavyweight boxer hasn't earned this right to cry on camera. Anderson's crying on camera will continue to give his opponents the psychological edge over him, thus Bakole was bound to smash him apart. Best thing for Jared Anderson would be to relocate to a more rugged, a more tougher, a more masculine environment such as Kazakhstan, or The Congo, or England where such crybaby antics would be quickly shutdown. He will learn quickly to keep his tears between himself and God Almighty, not to be shared on camera with the rest of the world, unless he earns this right. Until then, upcoming British Heavyweights, the likes of Fabio Wardley, Moses Ituama, Fisher, Solomon Dacres and even David Adeleye would be looking at Jared Anderson as a crybaby. This would be the best move for Anderson to make as he does have the physical potential to go beyond his current level of a NABF champion and reach the higher level of a British heavyweight title contender.
The British got the Commonwealth title going on as well. Between the British and the Commonwealth titles fighters at the Wardley/Clarke level got so much opportunity to make money fighting in the UK. That can only be a good thing.
This is any British fighters elevate quicker I'm the rankings and are generally more prepared. Chisora, Whyte huge headliners despite never having a title. Dubois more prepared for AJ than most thought possible. Wardley already world ranked.
Clarke was never much cop. He was never world level as a professional. He was a team GB amateur automaton, never suited to professional boxing. The habits he learnt as an amateur meant he was never going to make it as a professional. And such a level gets found out regardless at fringe world level even if he gets moved more slowly. It’s better weed that type out earlier in the process otherwise time and money can be wasted on fighters who aren’t much cop.
So if Price had exactly the same fights as Wilder leading up to the world title fight with Stiverne, which fighters do you feel were the ones who would have battered him? Remember he would have more fights for experience You may or may not be correct but I am not sure he would have lost to any of them at that time Some fighters don't recover from a loss but have alot of confidence when Undefeated. If he did get to that stage going that route he possibly could have got to a world title fight
Stiverne from the first Wilder fight KOs Price. If he doesn't Ortiz would. Artur Szpilka probably would've posed problems for Price but he was pretty chinny too
Charles Martin became a world champion without having as big a fight on the way up as Clarke did for the British title. I don't think winning a world title damaged his career