Just watched Baer-Braddock. Baer weighed 209. He looked really poor to me. Braddock, who let's be honest, was a journey man level tough guy, and he hit Max at will. Chin, body, head wherever and whenever he wanted to hit Max. Baer was slow of foot and hands. Zero defense and of course looked like he would rather have been in a brothel. I don't think Max could survive top ten HW's from the 60's onwards. Even Floyd Patterson would toy with him, and that's as bad as it gets.
You have poo pooed Max Baer, Tony Galento, Rex Layne, Jim Braddock and Billy Miske off the top of my head.
Baer at his best would be a dangerous assignment for Patterson. Max was bigger, better and more powerful than Johannson when he really showed up to fight.
So one off performance erases wins over Carnera, Schmeling, Schaaf, Levinsky, Farr, Comiskey and Galento.
lol show me one bout where he displayed good defensive skills, and any semblance of a jab. Even in one of the bouts touted here as one of his best against Galento, we can plainly see him duck INTO punches from a guy half a foot shorter than him.... punches that he wouldn't have been hit by otherwise. Yeah I'm sure someone here will explain in depth how that was actually a genius technique lost to the ages.
Yeah, a real Murderers Row right there. Farr, I grant you, was a good boxer. As was Schmeling who had his one day in the sun vs Louis. Won his belt on a DQ.
Oh come on! You're really telling me you wouldn't be shaking in your boots standing across the ring from this? This content is protected
Despite that clip, Galento was like Tua. 225 pounds of pure power with a left hook that could dent steel and a cast iron chin. I oftentimes think Galento vs Tua might be a draw or a narrow SD win for either fighter if they fought in their respective primes.
Beating Louis was no small feat. And Schmeling didn't just beat Louis, he knocked him out. It wasn't like a close 15 round split Decision win that could have gone the other way.