The more time passes the more I think the two fights between Bowe and Golota ruined both fighters. Andrew was just gunshy after those bouts. If it's after those bouts, Ike crushes him in total can fashion. Before that, it's a very competitive fight which Ike takes by Dec. or late round KO.
Both are lunatics, but one seemed to deliver when the chips were down, while the other fell apart. That probably answers your question.
Golota was a far better technician at the time of the Bowe fights. Ike is an unskilled labourer in comparison, but you can't rely on Golota at all, he was wound up way too tight for boxing, so who knows.