Better 2 Top Wins: Vitali Klitschko or Ike Ibeabuchi

Vitali's best 2 wins are Corrie Sanders and Samuel Peter. Ike's best 2 wins are David Tua and Chris Byrd. Who's 2 top wins are better? Vitali of course have more depth in his resume, but we're only looking at this subject at hand.

 

I think Sanders would beat Byrd. Tua beats Peter. So it's probably a draw.

 

Ike

 

Ike
Sanders a decade past his best , out of shape and only turned up for a retirement check.
Peter was heavier than Vitali. Out of shape and washed.

Byrd and Tua were undefeated and at their best.

 

Definitely, Ike. As mentioned above, Sanders and Peter were in dreadful shape when they fought Vitali. Nobody wanted to fight Tua when Ibeabuchi bested him.

 

Such a shame that the world wasn't able to see him challenge for the world title, he was a fight away from that title shot or his next fight could've been a Lennox fight, he was ranked as high as #2 by the IBF, just below his former opponent Tua

 

agreed.

 

Great question nd the answer is Ike's even thought the more I watch the Tua fight I feel Tua edged him .. still very competitive choice ..

 

Tua and Byrd are the better wins

 

Sanders would beat Byrd.

Adamek would beat Tua.

 

Ike

 

Ike.

Sanders was inactive out of shape and at the end of his career.

Peter was also past his best.

Byrd was in his prime and actually has a win over Vitali in his prime.

Tua was at his absolute peak.

 

Maybe. But Tua would beat Sanders, and Byrd would beat Peter

 

I'll edge with the majority - Ike.

 

I think Ike’s wins because he was beating two prime opponents. Of course it should be noted that Vitali was coming out of a lengthy retirement when he fought and beat Sam Peter