Shakur Stevenson is the best boxer in the world

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Joeywill, Jul 13, 2025 at 3:05 PM.


  1. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,140
    2,065
    Aug 2, 2021
    When Tank stops ducking we will find out
     
  2. AdamT

    AdamT Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    5,743
    10,120
    Sep 18, 2019
    You go where the money is
    Credit to fighters away from home, but what choice do they have? Why should Americans be expected to fight away when the money is at home?

    Conor mcgregor in his prime was way more popular than all these guys and where did he fight? In the States of course. He always wanted a show in Dublin and may eventually have gotten it, but it's not by accident that he didn't participate in Uk/Irish cards once he rose to fame

    Again, not a dig at anyone including usyk who is fighting in Dubois hometown and he doesn't have to. Big credit for that, but I don't think it should be held against fighters fighting where the money is if giving a choice. Now crooked officials etc is something else entirely
     
    im sparticus, Joeywill and Pimp C like this.
  3. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,058
    128,859
    Jul 21, 2009
    Rules for thee but not for me.

    Everyone has to come to the US to prove themselves and fight our boys on a heavily stacked deck but our best boys should never have to travel to their foreign opponent's backyards and do so

    The HUGE difference is when foreigners fight in the US vs Americans the deck is heavily stacked with a home ref and three home judges for world title fights the vast majority of the time, even done it for undisputed ones numerous times too

    But when Americans fight outside the US vs foreigners in world title fights the same never happens

    I have only found one instance of a foreigner fighting in their opponent's country in a world title fight outside the US where they did that and it was during Covid restrictions

    All I want is fairness I am not asking for a stacked deck like they do in the US or any unfair advantage

    Do you think this is fair?

    I have no problem with American people, I like them as much as I do any other group of peoples, but this is something which is clearly very unfair

    Name one current American fighter who has fought their foreign opponent in their country in a world title fight with a home ref and three home judges?

    I just listed 6 times Loma alone has done so in just 21 fights

    Kovalev vs Ward II and 2 - US ref and three US judges

    Kovalev vs B-Hop - - US ref and three US judges

    Loma x 6

    Josh Taylor vs JCR - US ref and three US judges and it was for undisputed

    Charlo vs Korobov - US ref and three US judges

    Charlo vs Castano - Neutral ref (extremely rare over there) and three home judges for 1st fight, US ref and three US judges for the rematch, after, as with Kovalev vs Ward 1 they robbed the away fighter. And this was for undisputed too

    Shakur vs Zepeda - US ref and three US judges

    Teofimo vs Kambosos - US ref and three US judges

    I can keep doing this all day

    Now watch

    Inoue vs Fulton in Japan - all the officials from neutral countries

    Haney vs Kambosos I and II - all the officials from neutral countries

    Kovakev vs Yarde in Russia - all the officials from neutral countries

    Kovalev vs Chilemba in Russia - all the officials from neutral countries

    Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Robson, Korobov, Castano, JLC, Lemos, Mattysee, Kotelnik to name but a few off the top of my head who have been robbed in the US vs North American fighters. How many times have the fighters they were robbed against: Haney, Salido, Ward, Valdez, Jermall, Jermell, Floyd, Hitchins, Judah, Alexander been robbed vs foreigners?

    Exactly


    If it's so easy to do and doesn't greatly increase your chances or losing via hook and crook then why are so many so opposed to doing it or would never dare do so a fraction as much as Usyk and other road warriors have? Why did some of the greats categorically to ever do it once in their entire careers?


    Haney would not have fought Kambosos in Australia if the officials were Australian.

    Would Floyd had fought Manny in the Philippines, JLC in Mexico, Maidana in Argentina, let alone with a home ref and three home judges? Of course not

    Ward would never have dared fight Kovalev or Beterbiev in Russia or Adonis and Beterbiev in Canada, let alone with a home ref, a home ref and 1, 2, or 3 home judges. Not in a million years

    Remember that episode of Fight Camp 360 The Super Six where all the promoters and organizers were in a meeting where things were getting heated because Ward didn't want to travel and got to have all his fights at home which he admitted was a big advantage for him?

    His team wouldn't even allow a single neutral judge for the rematch against Kovakev despite Kovalev being robbed of all his world titles in the first fight, affording Ward the opportunity to win all of them off him in his home country, and having a full deck of a home ref and three home judges the first time even though Kovalev was the unified champ

    Shakur on whether he would fight 122 pounder Inoue in Japan

    This content is protected



    The are numerous factors which can combine to make home advantage advantageous and individual ones alone can often mean the difference between going home with an L or a W

    Richie Woodhall

    ''Fighting away from home opens your eyes. People were knocking on my door at 4am. They took me for a medical and said they'd lost all my forms, which was nonsense. I was taken on journeys that were supposed to be 15 minutes but lasted an hour.''

    ''I lost fair and square on the night and there are no excuses but things were bad from the start. Everything is against you. The crowd, the promoter and the local people, they try to make it as uncomfortable as possible. If you win a title abroad then you're a true champion, no doubt.''

    ---Richie Woodhall on facing Keith Holmes in the US.

    This is how honest Woodhall is. How many times have you seen a fighter do this, let alone a reigning world champion?

    Both his reaction and post-fight interview

    Timestamped

    This content is protected






    Iceman John Scull
    ''Mr. Scully, How difficult is it for a fighter from North America to train for a fight at home and then leave for an overseas fight a week or two before? You hear people talk about the adjustment, time zones and stuff, what is that like? Is it a difficult process for a fighter? - Pat in Maine

    ICE: I found it to be a mentally tough task to go there partly because of all the horror stories you've heard over the years. Did I get there in enough time? Will the time change affect me? Will the climate or the water or the food and the different altitude affect me? You find yourself asking a lot of questions. I don't know if it was nerves or jet lag or a combination of both but I know that when I fought Henry Maske for the IBF title back in 1996 in Germany there was not even one night there, including the night before the fight, that I was able to fall asleep before day break.''

    ''Kovalev did it the hard way'' meaning in his opponent's backyards and on the road


    -- Andre Ward

    The worst part about this is you all damn well know I'm right but you won't even concede I am and that it's unfair. You'll just be like.. ''We know he's right but Grrrrrr!''
     
    CST80 and LoveThis like this.
  4. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,058
    128,859
    Jul 21, 2009
    I'll reply to your other posts later
     
  5. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,140
    2,065
    Aug 2, 2021
    I think neutral sight would be most fair. It's not always feasible.
     
  6. bandeedo

    bandeedo Loyal Member Full Member

    35,881
    23,764
    Feb 19, 2007
    its all a bunch of fanboy bull**** used to inflate one fighter over another. you think they apply it when an american or unknown mexican goes over there and ko's their local hero? was the american twice as good for going over there and winning, or their hero twice as bad for losing to the foreigner?
     
    Pimp C, Joeywill and AdamT like this.
  7. redz215

    redz215 Active Member Full Member

    951
    9
    Oct 4, 2008
    I don't think he's the best boxer in the world, but he's damn good. I witnessed the Stevenson vs Zepeda fight live. Big respect to Shakur. He didn't need to fight in the pocket for most of the fight, but he did. He stood calm and deflected/evaded many of William's shots. When he let his hands go, he was visibly the sharper and more accurate puncher. Stevenson showed that he could stand in front of Zepeda and still beat him. Had Shakur used his legs more, he most likely would have beaten Zepeda more decisively.
     
    Pimp C, Joeywill and AdamT like this.
  8. Dorrian_Grey

    Dorrian_Grey It came to me in a dream Full Member

    2,579
    4,271
    Apr 20, 2024
    I agree, what I was angling at when I was talking about looking past athletic traits is more so about how many people will argue that P4P is about whether you upscaled or downscaled fighters into different divisions, which one would come out on top most often. I personally don't really like P4P lists and think that this sort of thinking doesn't really do justice to the diverse range of styles and talents that we have in the sport today but what I do object to is how some people will look solely at athletic traits and will have arguments about H2H match-ups boil down to "He hits too hard" or "He's too fast to get beaten by a guy like that." What interests me more is how fighters use their athletic gifts and weave them into a cohesive style through their boxing ability. As an aside, I do actually think that Wilder is more skilled than he gets credit for, his unflappable self-belief in his own ability to get off a clean right hand is honestly quite admirable and his ability to measure distance, maintain range with the jab, bait out punches by probing, and his quickness on the counter are all pretty impressive, at least during his prime. What I think is important is understanding how fighters use their skill to get the best out of their athletic abilities, more so than being vowed by the flashiness of speed or power.

    To me, the things Shakur does in the ring are immensely impressive. His game is incredibly well-rounded and he does a lot of things which I haven't seen any of Shakur's contemporaries do, or if they do, it isn't as polished as how Shakur does it. I think Shakur's defence is well beyond anyone else in the sport at the moment and I consider him the best inside fighter in the game today. Even with something as simple as hand-fighting, Shakur is able to be multi-faceted in how he engages in hand-fighting and then turns these engagements into offensive opportunities on top of being defensive traffic. It's not only how skilled he is in so many different areas but also how intricate his skills are and how he varies the reason he's using them for. It's not always too flashy but it is immensely skilful.
     
    Pimp C, Joeywill and AdamT like this.
  9. Mark Anthony

    Mark Anthony Internet virgin Full Member

    7,303
    3,381
    May 17, 2023
    No power.
     
    Joeywill likes this.
  10. Grinder

    Grinder Dude, don't call me Dude Full Member

    5,828
    2,515
    Mar 24, 2005
    Shakur scrapes past Zepeda, and this is now placing him in p4p contention?

    Usyk, Bivol, Inoue, Beterbiev, and Crawford are clearly ahead.
     
    CST80 likes this.
  11. AdamT

    AdamT Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    5,743
    10,120
    Sep 18, 2019
    Good analysis again
     
    Dorrian_Grey likes this.
  12. CooperKupp

    CooperKupp “B.. but they all playin NBA basketball again!” Full Member

    2,095
    4,327
    Aug 28, 2022

    :deal::deal::deal:

    I KNEW the shakur praising from the usual suspects was going to get outta hand years ago once he got a halfway decent win. He wasn’t even impressive the other night and lacks serious pop. He’s extremely fortunate Loma has been out of prime for the last five years and I think Linares would’ve probably stopped him too. I just don’t see anything that really stands out about him that warrants the praise he gets by some. Even his amateur credentials are ok but nothing to write home about. His biggest claim to fame before turning pro has been then now famous meme of him crying but other then that… :thinking::thinking:

    I mean shakur is a good fighter don’t get me wrong but Bivol, Usyk (Yes still) and Inoue are better CLEARLY and that’s just for starters.
     
    CST80, LoveThis and Serge like this.
  13. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,058
    128,859
    Jul 21, 2009
    Josh Taylor was undisputed at 140 at the time. He was the king of the division and held all the belts that Teofimo wanted to take from him but the little female dog refused to travel to the UK for the fight

    This content is protected


    Andre Ward flat-out refused to travel to his opponent's backyards, expecting everyone else to play by a set of rules that he refused to play by once in his career. Everyone had to come and fight him in his backyard or country but he would never dare do the same. He had home advantage for all of his fights, whether it be hometown, state or country, and home refs for every single one of his fights, whether it be hometown, state or country, 23 of them from Cali, and a scandalous amount of home judges, very often 3 or at worst 2 even vs foreigners

    He had home advantage vs every world class opponent he fought and home ref for all his fights, a massive advantage for a filthy dirty serial cheat like him whose style and success was heavily attributed to his incessant fouling and octopus grabbing

    Ali had no problem travelling and fighting in his opponent's backyards but Floyd who was supposedly the face off boxing and TBE didn't do it once

    Again

    Shakur

    Would you fight Inoue, the way smaller 122 pounder Inoue, in Japan?

    This content is protected


    What do you think Usyk would say if he was asked that question? He would say ''no problem'' immediately. How do we know? Because we've seen him say exactly that numerous times and forge a career doing it unlike these have gloves won't travel deck-stackers who need all the advantages in their favour as many as can be wangled in their favour before they will sign on the dotted line, to the extent that they're almost are or are rolling with loaded dice, to achieve 'greatness'

    I think he might fight a foreigner in their backyard one day but I guarantee it won't be with them having a home ref and three home judges, nor even 2 home judges, that is deemed as extremely unfair, completely outrageous even, by many fighters and fans over there. The irony couldn't be more priceless

    So you have to ask yourself if it's so easy, why are so many of these 'greats' and the best fighters in the world so averse to doing so and why did they categorically refuse to do it even once?

    Does the chance of you losing, either via hook or crook, increase if your travel to your opponent's backyard? Yes or no? Trying to workout why they call it home 'advantage'?

    Are you more likely to get robbed at home or in your opponent's backyard? Which one is it? The answer is right there in front of your eyes because we see it on almost a weekly basis. :facepalm:

    Heroes of yours categorically refused to do it, told you they would never do, and never actually did it but it's so easy. They steadfastly refused to do it for a reason :facepalm:

    Usyk is literally the complete antithesis to them. He doesn't care if every advantage is stacked against him, even when he's already giving away huge physical advantages and big youth advantage.
     
  14. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,058
    128,859
    Jul 21, 2009
    I think he's very talented but, as I said, had he turned pro at the same age Loma did he wouldn't eve be a world champion in one weight class yet, unless he was brave enough to fight for a world title in his 2nd or 3rd fight like Loma did which is highly unlikely and would he have done so in his opponent's country with a home ref and three home judges like Loma did vs GRJ and it was essentially a home fixture for Mexican Salido fighting a Ukrainian in Texas. Of course he wouldn't. Not in a million years

    So had Loma turned pro at the same age as Shakur, which gets conveniently ignored by so many, 135 would be BARE minimum his SIXTH WEIGHT CLASS, not his THIRD and he would be a six weight world champion 100% (people can try and argue otherwise but they will fail) not a three weight one and he would've won three of the four belts in his sixth weight class and been robbed of being undisputed in his sixth weight class vs a 20lbs heavier, almost 6'' longer reach gigantic weight bully in said weight bullies backyard with a home ref and three home judges when past his prime at 35 y/o.

    How many fighters become undisputed in their sixth weight class or at 35 y/o in their opponent's backyards vs a 20lbs heavier near 6'' longer reach opponent? How many even attempt to do so? Crawford's about to attempt to do it vs a Clenelo who is well past his best and barely any bigger than him but he's a god and as brave as they come for doing so in his own country

    And, as said, it would be Loma's sixth weight class bare minimum. It might be his seventh and more had he turned pro even younger

    How many win three of the four belts in their sixth weight class, let alone on the road like he did winning them individually vs much or way bigger opponents? But he's a ''hype job'' and Shakur is the best fighter in the sport, for beating Herring, Valdez, and Zepeda :facepalm:



    Let's see Shakur try and do that and he will have to go up higher than 147 to at least 154 to be giving away those kind of physical advantages
     
    CST80 likes this.
  15. MetalLicker

    MetalLicker I Am Full Member

    23,325
    25,966
    Feb 10, 2011
    People usually overreact after a fight, but people need to face reality.

    Zepeda's resume is a bunch of nobodies, other than Farmer. He's got a gift in the first fight and barely scrapped by in the 2nd. And we all saw what happened to Farmer against Schofield.

    I know some people were high on Zepeda and some people clearly overrated him. I never thought once that Zepeda could beat Stevenson based on what I saw against Farmer.

    Stevenson needs better competition and test those skills against better fighters. That's how you prove your skills at the highest level. Bivol didn't get on the list until he schooled Canelo, who was ranked P4P #1 at the time. He didn't get on the P4P list by beating Pascal, Barrera and Smith Jr. After he beat Canelo, he then beat Ramirez and then beat another undisputed champion in Beterbiev before he was widely recognized in the top 5.

    But here we are, saying Stevenson is the best fighter in the world because he beat a guy who had very much a paper record.
     
    hoopsman likes this.