Greater Fighter Marvin Hagler or Floyd Mayweather junior?

Lloyd Decemberclimate. Better longevity, titles in more divisions, undefeated, deeper and overall better list of wins.

Really wish I could say Hagler, but it's just all Decemberclimate in basically every category.

 

Hagler for me

 

Floyd Mayweather in my opinion, I think the careers of these two great champions say this clearly. Mayweather has a 26-0 record in world title fights, while Hagler has a 13-1-1 record here. Both have been at the top for years (Mayweather a few more). Then we look at the names (which for me matter more than the numbers), and here too I think Mayweather has something extra. Hagler defeated Hearns and Duran (he wasn't as strong at middleweight as he was at lightweight, but he still became world champion at 160 pounds at age 37), then other good and very good fighters (Minter, Briscoe, Antuofermo...). Floyd defeated Pacquiao, Cotto, Marquez, De La Hoya, Maidana, the undefeated Hatton, Castillo, the undefeated Corrales and others.

 

I believe the Four Kings would have a winning record against Floyd. It's just a hypothesis that can't be proved or disproven. That being said Floyd has a better resume than Marvin.

 

Mayweather for me. Hagler was awesome and true ATG. All respect to him. But Floyd has too many achievements and depth.

 

The bald headed one.

 

Money May and as great as Hagler was, it’s not really that close imo.

This content is protected

 

Floyd based on sheer achievements and mastery of his style. He was rarely troubled across all those weight classes and consistently made it look easy.

 

Floyd. It's kind of hard for a one division champion to rank over a multi division one unless they were in a stacked era. I don't think Hagler was in a stacked era of actual middleweights.

 

They would, but also should be expected to win anyway due to size advantage.

Hagler was a MW, Leonard & Hearns won their first titles at 147 (as opposed to 147 being Floyd’s 4th divisional title).

 

That sums it up pretty well.

 

Floyd.
But I would like to point out something. Just look at Hagler's career, the segment from his loss to Bobby Watts to the point when he fought Bennie Briscoe. How often he fought and how many good fighters he fought in that period of 26 months. If Floyd had ever had to go through that, I doubt that he would have been undefeated.

 

i agree with both.

 

Dont like doing this but its Floyd