I was studying Sandy Saddler's resume and I noticed that in his 3rd fight against Paddy DeMarco there was a strong disagreement between the judges. Ref and the 1st judge scored it in favor of Demarco 8-1-1 and 6-4 respectively, whereas the 2nd judge had it 6-3-1 in favor of Saddler. Other fights that come to mind: Pintor-Zarate Judge: Art Lurie 143-142 Judge: Harold Buck 143-142 Judge: Bob Martin 133-145 (scartissue explained to me that Martin scored the fight using a 5-point system and when informed about his mistake proceeded to double all scores ) Golovkin-Alvarez 1 - infamous Adelaide Byrd scorecard
I wouldn't be surprised if the judge put their scores in the wrong column Here is my own score for reference:
Jose Navarro - high quality Super Flyweight Contender from the 2000s - lost two split decision fights when one of the judges did not see him lose a single round, yet the other two judges went against him. It first happend against Kawashima, then against Mijares.
The scores from the first Jimmy McLarnin v Barney Ross fight were: 12-2-1 Ross 13-1-1 Ross (so far they seem like they're watching the same fight) 9-1-5 McLarnin ???
Anyone know if he had one eye,The graphic i saw of him on hbo made me have a look at his cards https://boxrec.com/wiki/index.php/Al_Siciliano Junior Jones v Tracy Harris Patterson had wild scores
Antuofermo vs. Minter I: 141-144, 145-143, 137-149 The US judge and the Venezuelan judge saw it as a close fight, with the American actually favoring Minter, but the English judge was all in on his countryman. Gonzalez vs. Oguma III: 147-143, 146-149, 145-145 Neither the Venezuelan nor the Japanese judge saw this as a terribly close fight, but Marty Denkin scored it even and got a kick in the ass from an angry spectator as a reward. Actually, maybe the Japanese judge did see it as a close one, given that he doled out ten even rounds. Toney vs. McCallum II: 117-110, 117-110, 114-114 This is one in which the dissenting vote was actually the voice of reason drowned out in the winds. In no way did Toney dominate this fight. Carrasco vs. Ramos II: 7-6, 9-5, 5-8 One judge thought that Mando Ramos barely squeaked it out. Another thought that he was a clear winner. Dick Young thought that the Spaniard had convincingly retained his title.
Emmanuel Augustus loss by SD to Courtney Burton Ed Mosley 92-97 Robert Paganelli 90-99 Jake Jack Richards 98-94
