Bowe by stoppage around halfway. His jab,inside work and uppercut would repeatedly catch a brave but outclassed AJ.
Both are overrated but Bowe had more dog in him and had a better chin so I'd favour Bowe by stoppage in the middle rounds. But Bowe didn't face many notable punchers especially Super Heavyweight sized so Bowe is a bit of an unknown quantity in that regard.
Bowe, I think his toughness and aggression carries him here, he can continue after AJ lands but AJ can’t do the same.
I favor Bowe, but it looks to me from the comments here that the pendulum has swung a bit too far the other way.
I have Bowe not winning, but battering AJ. Prime Bowe, maybe Holyfield 1 is a head to head nightmare for most and I think he beats AJ everywhere, takes his heart, takes his soul and batters him. KO8.