Who is the best Flyweight in boxing's history ?

It depends what you mean by 'best'. If you mean a combination of resume, accomplishments and H2H ability then for me it's Miguel Canto. I would like to pick Wolgast but there isn't that much footage of him.

 

Jimmy Wilde, no other correct answer.

 

It's between Miguel Canto, Jimmy Wilde, Pancho Villa.

 

Imo the greatest, which is based on who had the best record at Flyweight in the eras in which they competed, is Jimmy Wilde.

1. Wilde
2. Canto
3. Pascualw
4. Wolgast
5. Lynch
6. Genaro
7. Villa
8. Kingpetch
9. Obha
10. Archavallo

 

I don’t know the division super well but Canto always impressed me immensely. I believe at the weight he is the best I’ve ever seen.

 

None of those.

To me, its between wild Jimmy Wilde and revolutionary Pancho Villa, but , career-wise, I favor Wilde. Just like, career-wise, I favor Muhammad Ali over Larry Holmes, Holmes over Mike Tyson, and Julio Cesar Chavez Sr over everyone who beat him later in his career, and Roberto Duran over everyone else that beat him and Sugar Ray Robinson over everyone who beat him, SPECIALLY, Tiger Jones, Ferd Hernandez and Joey Archer!!! LOL

 

He won the Ring's All Time Fly Championship.

 

You must surely have St. Santos at #11!!

 

No, but I only factor Flyweights in my rankings, so his exploits at Super Fly don't contribute to how I rank him at Fly.

He doesn't make my top 10 at Super Fly, either (sorry), but I'd rank him higher p4p than some who I have above him in both divisions.

 

I thought Gonzalez could be the Nicaraguan Chavez and go on a long 80 win streak.

I still love the guy!

 

I can see that. And where would you have Estrada?