Prime Bonavena replaces Galento against Louis in 1939. Could the heavyweight champion of South America become heavyweight champion of the world?
Louis would do what I saw not really anybody do? And that was conclusively shut Bonavena down, Louis was such a boxer and he’d KO him in about 4-6 rds, Louis’s hook is far shorter and more powerful then either Ali or Fraziers… Oscar would make it odd looking till he was turned into paste not overly intelligent of a fighter but he was an opportunist in the moment? He didn’t hesitate,I can’t phrase it any other way. JL is too savvy for OB to impress even in a loss.
In the sixth round Louis lands a flurry of lefts and rights to the head. The canvas rises and upends Oscar. That's the last thing he remembers.
Bonavena had a great chin, but major defensive liabilities. There's quite few easier ways of making a living than stepping into a boxing with the greatest offensive heavy in history with those glaring weaknesses . Joe Louis would turn Bonavena's face into ground beef before it's over. Giving the ref no choice but to stop the massacre with-in 8-9 rds.
Hi Buddy. Of course it's to get peoples opinions, and that's good, but matchups like this don't offer opinions, there is no questions as to who will win, a more pertinent thread might be how long Oscar would last, and there has been a tendency of late to again put up obvious winners in fantasy fights, I don't think it stretches anyone's imagination like say, Leonard v Robinson, or Ali v Louis, Greb v Monzon, where by the outcome isn't so certain, and the forum gets to see other members, thoughts and breakdowns, I have had my mind changed many times on who I think would win, by the informative opinions of our posters, it makes for good reading, so I am with Swag to a degree, how long before we see who wins Marciano or Wilde, I jest of course but... , no offence meant. stay safe buddy, chat soon. Mike.
Bonavena may not deck Louis like Galento but would put up a better fight. As ponderous as he was he had some ability to stay away and box carefully. He also was strong and rugged. I think he would last probably 7 or 8 rounds but run into too many power punches and finally a devastating combo.
Louis stops a tough Bonavena. Bonavena was unorthodox in the way he attacked as well (as was Galento) so maybe he could land something to drop Louis, but I believe Louis, for the most part, controls him with the jab and is able to time Bonavena as he rushes in, and he stops him as he wilts late on.