If we are going to say that, we might as well say the quintana win in the first fight was a fluke because williams was not focused. I mean come on a W is a W he got revenge in impressive fashion lets just leave it at that. For the record I would not mind a third fight to settle the score once and for all.
Quintana was knocked out HARD!...In the first! There's no way in hell many people would want a rematch if they come in 1st round (when there freshest), and a guy hits you one time, and crushes you. What that tells them, and also me is that this guy could knock Quintana out in any round if he sat down on a punch, and hit Quintana clean. People gave Williams a hard time for *slap* punches, and said he had no power...Only accumalation. PW proved them wrong by knocking him out 6x faster than hard hitting Cotto.
It's debatable that Williams got lucky with the punch itself, but Williams was more than lucky/fortunate that Quintana did such an unbelievably bad jab of protecting himself after he got hurt. There are people with no combat experience at all who would have done a better job of covering up then Quintana did. That was one of the worst displays of punch drunken non-evasive manuevering in championship boxing history.