I'll hazard a reasonably conventional guess - Ali Louis Lewis Holmes Foreman Marciano Wlad Johnson Holyfield Usyk Dempsey/Jeffries
I don't rate them H2H but based on their overall career, achievement, resume and impact on the sport. So, here is my top 10 even top 12 in which it is hard to put Mike Tyson, Frazier and Liston. 1: Joe Louis 2: Muhammad Ali 3: Larry Holmes 4: Lenox Lewis 5: Rocky Marciano 6: George Foreman 7: Wladimir Klitschko 8: Oleksander Usyk 9: James Jeffries 10: Evander Holyfield 11: Sam Langford 12: Jack Johnson All of these had better career than Tyson, Frazier and Liston.
Frazier has a better best win than most of your top 10. He also defended his title something like 9 successful title defenses, only lost to two guys, ranked #2 and #6 on your list.
Two of my favourite heavyweights regardless of ranking are Tommy Morrison and Ray Mercer. Patterson, Foreman and Dempsey are outside my top ten but I love them dearly..
Here's my favourite TEN heavyweights outside my top ten! 01 - Floyd Patterson 02 - Sonny Liston 03 - Ruslan Chagaev 04 - Sam Langford 05 - Harry Wills 06 - James Jeffries 07 - Archie Moore 08 - Eddie Machen 09 - Gary Mason 10 - Tony Thompson
Alexander Povetkin, Ruslan Chagaev, Carlos Takam, Johann Duhaupas, Anthony Joshua, Michael Spinks, Riddick Bowe, Trevor Berbick, all of them are outside my top 10 of the most strongest heavyweight in history.
Here's a top 10 outside my top 100... 01 - Ruslan Chagaev 02 - Gary Mason 03 - Tony Thompson 04 - Frank Bruno 05 - Derrick Chisora (assuming retired now) 06 - James Toney 07 - Walter Neusel 08 - Bryant Jennings 09 - Eddie Chambers 10 - Sammy Scaff This content is protected
Here's my top 6 outside my top 300. 01 - Sammy Scaff 02 - Steve Garber 03 - Audley Harrison (looks like a cat) 04 - JD Turner 05 - Michael Jack Johnson 06 - Battling Black Jack This content is protected
Always had a soft spot for Bugner he was treated disgracefully by the British boxing media. Also agree with @McGrain on Gary Mason he was a fun watch. A bit of a left field choice is John L Gardner his KO of Lorenzo Zanon is a real memory/highlight for me.