Undefeated retired fighter with no dodgy wins?

GGGfans · Apr 13, 2026

If I remember correctly, Marciano has two controversial fights and one fixed fight against Moore.

Dynamicpuncher · Apr 13, 2026

Macedoine62 said: ↑

Ricardo Lopez, Terence Crawford, Ji Won Kim, Rocky Marciano, Dmitry Pirog.

Also Lomachenko (two very controversial loses normally he is undefeated) & Yuri Arbachakov (The rematch against Chatchai Sasakul he's still injured; normally he would have been undefeated if he hadn't been forced to defend his belt again. At the time, the Japanese had tried to make him lose just before against Puma Toguchi, but against all odds the fight did not end in a decision) & Chayaphon Moonsri aka Wanheng Meenayothin (The fact is that his brother in law Panya Pradabsri's beat him twice but it's two robberies, especially the first one Wanheng Meenayothin was retired since 1 year before the fight, so he should have remained undefeated 54-0 or 55-0 normally. Then there was the defeat during the covid against his best friend Knockout CP Freshmart, but that was set up by the Thais for protect Knockout CP Freshmart for not defend his belt against the Olympic champion Hasanboy Dusmatov in the past, but this victory was against Wanheng who was already 38 years old). It's very sad with the death of his trainer at Camp Meenayothin, Wanheng was sacrificed for Petchyindee's two champions.
Click to expand...

Marciano had two controversial decisions vs Ted Lowry and Roland LaStarza.

Lomachenko clearly lost to Teofimo Lopez nothing controversial about that.

Flo_Raiden · Apr 13, 2026

Macedoine62 said: ↑

Ricardo Lopez, Terence Crawford, Ji Won Kim, Rocky Marciano, Dmitry Pirog.

Also Lomachenko (two very controversial loses normally he is undefeated) & Yuri Arbachakov (The rematch against Chatchai Sasakul he's still injured; normally he would have been undefeated if he hadn't been forced to defend his belt again. At the time, the Japanese had tried to make him lose just before against Puma Toguchi, but against all odds the fight did not end in a decision) & Chayaphon Moonsri aka Wanheng Meenayothin (The fact is that his brother in law Panya Pradabsri's beat him twice but it's two robberies, especially the first one Wanheng Meenayothin was retired since 1 year before the fight, so he should have remained undefeated 54-0 or 55-0 normally. Then there was the defeat during the covid against his best friend Knockout CP Freshmart, but that was set up by the Thais for protect Knockout CP Freshmart for not defend his belt against the Olympic champion Hasanboy Dusmatov in the past, but this victory was against Wanheng who was already 38 years old). It's very sad with the death of his trainer at Camp Meenayothin, Wanheng was sacrificed for Petchyindee's two champions.
Click to expand...

I thought Lopez should have lost to Rosendo Alvarez the first fight and was very fortunate to have it ruled a draw. Lomachenko clearly lost to Teo.

Mickc · Apr 13, 2026

Edwin Valero

Braindamage · Apr 13, 2026

Contro said: ↑

Salvador sanchez, Ricardo Lopez
Also ended their careers undefeated. Although i am not familiar enough with their careers to make a categorical statement
Click to expand...

Sanchez lost to a hometown favorite. At least that is what I read many years ago.

Lonsdale81 · Apr 13, 2026

Babality said: ↑

Ward - Lost Kov 1 fight for me
Floyd - 50/50 vs Castillo
Calzaghe - 50/50 Hopkins, Robin Reid
Click to expand...

My take on those is neither Reid or Hopkins did enough to beat Calzaghe. Ward clearly lost to Kovalev but outhusled him in tne second.. yes he low balled him but Kovalev should have returned in kind then.. & i haven't seen the Castillo fight in years but Floyd closed the door on it in the rematch.

Log in or Sign up

Undefeated retired fighter with no dodgy wins?

GGGfans Active Member Full Member

Dynamicpuncher Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

Flo_Raiden Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

Mickc Boxing Addict Full Member

Braindamage Baby Face Beast Full Member

Lonsdale81 Active Member Full Member

Log in or Sign up

Forums

Undefeated retired fighter with no dodgy wins?

GGGfans Active Member Full Member

Dynamicpuncher Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

Flo_Raiden Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

Mickc Boxing Addict Full Member

Braindamage Baby Face Beast Full Member

Lonsdale81 Active Member Full Member