My personal list: 15. Joe Bugner 14. Fabio Wardley (hard to tell) 13. Riddick Bowe 12. Joe Joyce 11. George Chuvalo 10. Nikolai Valuev 9. Muhammad Ali 8. David Tua 7. Ross Puritty 6. Filip Hrgovic (I think he is tied with Mercer, but his career is still currently ongoing.) 5. Ray Mercer (pre-neck injury) 4. Marion Wilson 3. Vitali Klitschko 2. George Foreman (comeback) 1. Oliver McCall
No Tex Cobb? Oleksandr Usyk? Marciano only down twice. Holyfield? Jim Jefferies deserves a shout. Why Bowe? He almost never fought punchers.
Mount Rushmore of HW chins | Boxing News 24 Fan Forum Randall Cobb? Larry Holmes? Joe Joyce out George Chuvalo No.2
Doing a top 20. In chronological order. Primary factor is the amount of times stopped and how many fights they had where they were at risk of being stopped. Langford Jeanette Gibbons Miske Dempsey Tunney Loughran Uzcudchin Risko Braddock John Henry Lewis Pastor Baksi Chinvalo Ali Jimmy Young Foreman Holyfield Toney Valuev Notes Louis would be included if chin doesn't include getting knocked down. If you look past the fact Schaaf was killed part of why he was killed is he was too tough for his own good. Early fighters dominate this list because it's easier to tell whose chin is good when there's more fights they could have been knocked out.
McCall certainly had a great chin, but saying he was Numero Uno of all time would be unfair to other heavyweights. In fact it's simply impossible to say. In his whole carreer McCall faced only 3 really big punchers - Lewis, Bruno and Davarryl Williamson. But Williamson had a tendency of fighting very cautious because of his glass jaw. I think Ray Mercer, for example, has faced more great punchers throughout his career. Morrison, Lewis, Cooper, Wlad, Witherspoon also had a hell of a right hand. Lewis landed everything and kicthen sink on him and couldn't put a dent on his chin. The same goes for Morrison, who was enormous puncher. Cooper knocked down granite chinned Holyfield but couldn't hurt Mercer. Wlad was probably the hardest puncher of them all and yes, he knocked down Mercer and eventually stopped him, but Mercer was 41 in that fight and still took tons of punishment before getting stopped. So, I would say, Mercer had even more proven chin than McCall since he faced far more huge punchers
Tyson had a really good chin. Looking at his later career and seeing the douglas ko gives the wrong Impression. Also to me vitali is above foreman. Foreman was taking punishment by holyfield, but vitali was taking everything lewis had including the uppercut. Also vitali was fighting more offensively, giving more options to be countered. Foreman wasn't as offensive, still more mindful of defense while attacking, managing everything from stamina to defense well and in balance. I think it is easier to take punches with that foundation. Vitali just had a crazy ability to take punches.
No one mentioned Wach Marion Wilson is super manly How come people say 38-48 y/o Foreman had a better chin than 20-28 y/o Foreman? How is that even possible? Because 38-48 y/o Foreman was 20-40lbs heavier than 20-28 y/o Foreman was So size matters Hence why when fighters move up in weight they typically get bigger James Toney got dropped at MW by Reginald Johnson but ate the best shots of Samuel Peter, Holyfield, Rahman etc. If the Toney who fought Johnson fought those guys he would've got his noggin knocked into the Stratosphere Toney had a great chin So if size matters, and it matters big A natural CW like Usyk eating shots from the likes of way bigger and naturally bigger career HW giants like AJ, Dubois, Belly, Chisora, and even Rico is far more impressive than natural HWs eating shots off same sized or smaller natural HWs A chimpanzee eating the shots off a gorilla or an Orangutan is more impressive than a gorilla or an Orangutan eating them So you can have CWs who have great chins like Usyk and Holyfield for example who can take the power of much or way bigger natural career HWs You can also have CWs like say Haye who hit like big punching big HWs But these things are not the norm or are anomalies The gorilla and orangutan are stronger, tougher and more powerful than the chimpanzee People often cite number of punchers fought too Mavrovic only really fought one puncher but it was a way bigger ATG puncher on Lewis who threw the kitchen sink on him and Mavrovic displayed an iron chin in that fight But Mavrovic was knocked out x 2 in the amateurs so that goes against him Lewis was a SHW sized HW who was usually the bigger or much bigger man Vitali too albeit iron chinned for sure Everyone Valuev fought was much smaller than him Even Ali was usually the bigger or much bigger man. Certainly Iron chinned though Hrgovic is a big guy too but all the punchers he's fought as a pro are his size, bigger or way bigger Big Bang Dubois Moses Adeleye Even Big Joe Joyce whilst not a one punch guy has a KO 93% and is a 270-280lb man mountain these days But Hrgovic actually turned pro at 223lbs and IIRC has weighed in the 220s for like 6 of his 22 fights and like under 235 like 9 times and he always had a great set of whiskers even as a teenager facing grown men and bigger or much bigger fighters Never dropped in the amateurs, had like 30 fights in the WSB over 5 rounds and he was 18 when he first fought in the WSB Also, he's never been down in sparring despite sharing a ring and going to war with murderous and massive punchers like Wlad, The Dosser, Haye, Dubois, Fabio among others David Haye on sparring Hrgovic and Hrgovic's chin This content is protected
There might be several journeymen who didn't have the talent or skill to make it but had a iron chin. Anyway what about Larry Holmes as a OM?. Dropped 7/8 times in 75 fights at heavyweight fighting till 52 is pretty solid stuff and Holmes was hit plenty.
My top 15 in no order. Oliver McCall Marion Wilson George Chuvalo Muhammad Ali Larry Holmes George Foreman Vitali Klitschko David Tua Tex Cobb Evander Holyfield Ray Mercer Filip Hrgovic Rocky Marciano Oleksandr Usyk Jimmy Young Honourable mentions. Nikolai Valuev, Pinklon Thomas, Jim Jefferies, Riddick Bowe, Mike Tyson, Joe Joyce.