I give credit to Hopkins going to Ecuador and fighting at high altitude... this fight also included two rare Hopkins Knockdows. Although the opposition wasn't that great... but the Atmosphere, literally was very hostile. Only locals would be able to fight in Ecuador without any serious adverse affect. My list is 1. RJJ 2 Hopkins/Calzaghe 4. then Toney --------------- Toney could've have been the best of all 4, if only he took training more seriously, watched his weight and was dedicated like Hopkins and Calzaghe.... in fact if he had the dedication and fitness of Hopkins or Calzaghe... Toney would easily be the best IMO with his granite chin and skills.... he was let down by his own unhealthy living and indiscipline. And for that, he deserves to be last, the others were all great Athletes and professionals, Toney was a fat fuc* who had great boxing skills..
1. Hopkins 2. Jones 3. Calzaghe 4. Toney Jones could be first and I wouldn't argue that vehemently. Jones' wins over Hopkins and Toney themselves are huge.
On merit: Jones Hopkins Toney Calzaghe However, due to the steroid issues: Jones (also has 1 positive test) Hopkins Calzaghe Toney