Is Manny Pacquiao a top 50 All-Time Great

I am guessing that I am one of the only posters who can put their money where their mouth is and give a definitive answer on this, as I have written a full p4p top 100 on this very forum and can post a link if anyone is interested in seeing who I have Pac above and below.

I placed Pac 41st in my p4p top 100 and I think that is the correct placing for now. So from me it is a YES, Pac is indeed a top 50 ATG.

 

This list is ****ing ****, it proves absolutely nothing!! atsch

Jack Johnson at 10th?! (ridiculously high)
Jack Dempsey at 11th?! (RIDICULOUSLY HIGH)
Ezzard Charles at 17th?! (ridiculously low)
Mickey Walker at 18th?! (ridiculously low)
Stanley Ketchel at 20th?! (ridiculously high)
George Foreman at 21st?! (RIDICULOUSLY HIGH)
Barney Ross at 23rd?! (ridiculously low)
Marcel Cerdan at 26th?! (ridiculously high)
Pernell Whitaker at 43rd?! (RIDICULOUSLY LOW)

Can someone explain to me why anyone would post a list showing Stanley Ketchel 23 places higher than Pernell Whitaker to make a serious point??


If you don't think Manny Pacquiao deserves to be ranked higher than George Foreman, you need help.

 

p4p he should be higher than tyson, foreman fraizer dempsey ansd johnson.

 

4got 2 include DLH in the list but 4 me at least 50 yes may be higher..IMO

 

no doubt and still :bbb

 

most of these are from the dawn of time in 20 years pac will be on everyones list hes already top 20 for me

 

no he is not top 50 atg yet.. he needs to beat hatton and floyd then he gets in.

he has accomplished nothing that floyd mayweather did.

 

yep

 

Notice how this guy only has one period in his first, long... sentence/paragraph, and two periods in the next two, short sentences in the next paragraph he started...:rofl

 

so what?

 

Nallege...seriously...I just dont know what you are on about like 90% of the time.

 

Grammar Nazi.

 

As if we needed any further evidence that you were the weirdest ****** on this forum, but thanks again anyway!! atsch

 

:good Thanks for making me laugh
Pac already topped mayweather before he even beat de la hoya

 

pac deserves all the credit that he is getting...this article is to downgrade him would losing your credibility..but to me you just lost yours. pacman's IMPACT is so huge that could elevate him into top 30 ATG. he may have lost to morales but he beat him twice. Pacman is so influencial that his terms are followed. that must be included in measuring his status as an atg... his contribution to the growth of boxing in the far east is so huge that is why he is a hero there. mexicans can not deny the fact that he is really a mexecutioner..

and again to discredit him in his win over sasakul and make speculation that sasakul would beat him 10 times. truly downgrade the quality of you post