Your Top10 welterweights of all time??

No, neither would be. Possibly top 20.

 

Along with Chavez and victories he should hold over Tito and Shane, he's beaten:

Fernando Vargas
Ricardo Mayorga
Oba Carr
Miguel Angel Gonzalez
Hector Camacho
Genaro Hernandez
Arturo Gatti
John John Molina
Jesse James Leija
Javier Castillejo
Rafael Ruelas
Jorge Paez
Wilfredo Rivera
Jeff Mayweather

That's not even including his official victories over Whitaker, Quartey, and Sturm, as I personally had him losing all 3 fights.

 

1 Jose Napoles
2 Thomas Hearns
3 Sugar Ray Leonard
4 Emile Griffith
5 Felix Trinidad
6 Pernell Whitaker
7 Luis Manuel Rodriguez
8 Mickey Walker
9 Jimmy McLarnin
10 Ted Kid Lewis

 

Ike Quartey is a better win than anything Mayweather achieved above 140lb.

 

Felix too high.
Leonard too low.
Hearns way too high.

 

Robinson
Leonard
Griffith
Walcott
Gavilan

Ross
Walcott
Walker
Napoles
Burley

 

my lower 9 is gonna take time but at 147 ill take SRR

 

Whitaker's resume sucks?? Wins over McGirt, Chavez, and arguably even a peak Oscar once he was well past-prime??

 

Put Robinson somewhere in the top 3 and this becoomes the best list yet....

 

Where the **** is Pernell Whitaker in most of these lists???? He's quite easily top 10 if not top 5 in any Welterweight case.

 

I didn't know where to put him, IMHO Napoles is the #1 Welterweight, Hearns at #2 sounds right as does Leonard at #3.

I'll do this

1 Jose Napoles
2 Thomas Hearns, Sugar Ray Robinson
3 Sugar Ray Leonard
4 Emile Griffith
5 Felix Trinidad
6 Pernell Whitaker
7 Luis Manuel Rodriguez
8 Mickey Walker
9 Jimmy McLarnin
10 Ted Kid Lewis

 

1.Sugar Ray Robinson
2.Henry Armstrong
3.Jose Napoles
4.Sugar Ray Leonard
5.Emile Griffith
6.Kid Gavilan
7.Tommy Hearns
8.Charley Burley
9.Mickey Walker
10.Roberto Duran

 

you're right about hearn's resume, and I guess if you are using resume as the main criteria the list is good...

H2H though I think Hearns beats them all but Leonard.

 

Not really. DEFINATELY not top 5

 

Terrible list. Especially considering a Cuban forgot Gavilan.