Should Cotto be in the P4P Top 10?

There are other guys that should be in there that didn't make it either.

 

agree


but cotto aint top ten material for me...all because he doesnt want to clinch just because "it aint his style" wtf?

seriously cotto has some issues on his defense....

 

My p4p would go like so

Pacquaio
Juan Manuel Marquez
Bernard hopkins
Shane Mosely
Israel Vasquez
Miguel Cotto
Ricky Hatton
Paul Williams
Kelly Pavlik
Chad Dawson

 

i guess people is consistent that calderon is > darchinyan

 

Watch the first 6 rounds of Cotto-Margo and try to honestly say hes not top ten if not top 5...Until the loaded gloves wore him down he was schooling Margo.

How soon we forget that there was no one we wanted Floyd to fight more than Cotto about a year ago. Then he gets beat by plaster-wraps and Pacman whoops on a drained Oscar and all of the sudden we'd much rather see Pac-Floyd or Shane-Floyd??????


Please.

 

He was not schooling Margo. He boxed very well in round 1, and controlled the action. He lost rounds 2 and 6. In rounds 3,4,5, Cotto was steadily going into survival mode after getting hurt in round 2. Margo was dictating the pace, was pinning Cotto on the ropes, and was getting off a lot of shots. I gave Cotto rounds, 3,4, and 5 based on clean punching, but Margo arguably inflicted more damage in those rounds.

 

Yes. (Even tho the entire P4P list is always like an Opinion/*******....)

 

:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl

 

Yes, he should be in it.

1 - Pacquiao
1 = Marquez
2 - Hopkins
3 - Vasquez
4 - Mosley
5 - R Marquez
6 - Calderon
7 - Hatton
8 - Darchinyan
9 - Cotto

Paul Williams next in line.

 

yes.

 

Getting a little sick of all this pound for pound talk now. Everybody's list is subjective and we're all going to be bias towards our favourite fighters, particularly if there is a talent we're unaware of. I am yet to see a list that two people agree on. but to answer the above question Cotto would be in my top ten, just.

 

Very good list. very fair

 

You are forgeting the cast!!! But anyways, I still think the 1001 P4P lists running around are totally worthless anyways.

 

You mean the one in the Cotto fight that there is no evidence that it exists? The one that the Commission cleared Margo of having in that fight? I can't base rankings based on what could've happen if something that there isn't any proof happened didn't happen.

 

Challenger??? Cotto is a Champion!!:deal