Marlon Starling vs Wilfred Benitez

Prime Benitez edges him, but any other version, Starling has a chance to reverse.

 

been allot of years since I saw starling fight, are similar in allot of ways. would have to go with Benitez prime for prime. but close and a snooze fest.

 

Both GREAT GREAT boxers!! Marlon more predicable?? I loved Wilfred he was PURE CLASS when young .Shaded a Great Antonino (Kid Pambele) Cervantes at 18!!!:hey

 

Bad style matchup of two great fighters. It'd be tough to pick a winner. I'd go with Benitez because he got more done in the ring. Not by much, though.

 

Actually it was 17.

 

Prime Benitez beats a prime Starling in a snoozer of a chess match that only boxing afficianados would appreciate. Not many punches would land in this one, IMO.

 

I'm not sure if it would be such a snoozer. Very few punches would be landed surely but both fighters had a tendency to stand their ground and trade punches.

Starling picks apart Lloyd Honeyghan:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18mxprozRbg

Benitez does like-wise to Maurice Hope:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1nU2zI74ds

 

If both are at their best, I would say Benitez barely edges Starling by a point, half a point in England, the gap widens if one shows up less than 100%.

 

It might b hard 2 imagine Starling doing better than Benitez vs his opponents , but it is hard 2 imagine Benitez doing better than Starling against his opponents . Benitez would have had d better looking scorecards but 1 must wonder more about d stoppages (both ways) .
But then Benitez' size advantage would have helped him in this comparison (which is h2h obviously) .

 

Starling beat nongreats, but no one like Benitez speed and ability. Benitez beats Starling by decision. Not an action packed fight. Starling blocked punches with his gloves buy Wilfred blocked by defense. Wilfred's defense is a better way to defend obviously.

 

While Duran was definitely much greater than Honeyghan Benitez didn't come close 2 destroying him despite being d bigger man and d younger man by 7 years , 3 negligible facts I suppose , but Starling did destroy a slightly younger , slightly bigger man in Honeyghan so it's not like Benitez won this comparison at all .

 

I doubt if Benitez would have beaten Curry more than Starling did and I doubt that Starling would have been stopped by Leonard , then I also doubt that Benitez would have done as good vs a prime Michael Nunn .