James Toney vs Carl Froch @ 168

Toney/Froch at 168 would be a clear demonstration of why James is called "Lights Out.":yep

 

Shutout for Lights Out Toney. Froch has a solid chin so he would last 12, put Toney would completely dominate the fight. Very skilled fighter.

 

James Toney is a legend!!! in his prime he waz a animal!!,Carl Froch is a pretty good fighter and has a hell of a jaw,But i see Toney being too much for Froch,winning by late stoppage or wide UD

 

are some people that bored?!

 

Toney at his best was on another level to Froch and stop him late. It wouldn't be vaguely competitive. However Toney looked like shite at times (Tiberi) so who knows?

 

Toney KO 5 In a one sided fight.

 

Taylor made Froch look bad for 11 rounds, Toney will make this look embarrassingly easy; there will be a good few 10-8 rounds in this one

 

What rock have you been living under for the last 20 years?

 

For Toney to ever get down to fight at 168 he's gonna have to cut a leg off! He's 3 stone over even when in full training. I think his days at 12 stone are long gone mate.

 

Toney might lose a round or two that he takes off, but that's it. His chin is too good for Froch to hurt him, and he'd just avoid 90% of his slow-ass punches anyway. Toney picks him apart.