Who do you rate higher trinidad or mosley?

Felix Trinidad

 

I don't see it.

Compare the likes of

Trinidad
Mosley
DLH
Vargas
MAB
Morales
Whitaker
Quartey
RJJ
Hopkins

to

Cotto
Williams
Clottey
Berto
Quintana
Hatton
Valero
Guzman
Pavlik
Dawson

Todays fighters look good against each other, but what happens when you put an old fighter like Hopkins with a prime Pavlik? Or an old fighter like osley against Margarito?

A Prime Mosley KO Cotto imo.
A Prime Hopkins KO Pavlik and Taylor on the same night.

Just look at the HW division today as a measuring stick to see how much talent boxing has lost.

 

I would say mosley, but not by much......mosley has the more impressive victories IMO....and is stil relenquishing young guns in his mid to late 30's.....i think some fall in love with tito's power a little too much, sure he was a great fighter.....but overall top to bottom mosley is rated higher.....

 

Trinidad and for those who were there not just comparing resumes you know why. At one point Tito was the life of boxing he went on a run that still to this day i have not seen copied. fighting undefeated fighter after undefeated fighter winning belt after belt. **** if we had a fighter like that today... man i wish.

Quick question for real though, who did Mosley ever fight at lightweight? great resume at welter but i can't think of any big wins without going to boxrec at 135?

 

atsch

Dont you have to win those fights???

Its the same argument that I always make about Duran..Fighting great fighters dont make you great unless your winning the fights. Mosely's resume trumps Tito's EASY.

Tito's greatest wins---Oscar---Vargas---Reid...One he didnt really win, and the other two he had to cheat to win, punching both in the nuts a number of times to slow them down when he was hurt.

No way in hell should this even be close...but this is ESB afterall..Home of the blind sackswingers:hi:

 

More then Tito ducking Forrest???

 

TITO and it's not even debatable..

 

Tito's performance against Oscar showed how good he really was.

 

Yea but Tito has never been assraped back to back by Forrest and Winky.. :deal

 

Um, he certainly was by Winky, much worse may I add :deal

 

Yeah and he ducked forrest.

 

Yea but Tito was way past his prime and rusty..

Not only that, but he only lost once to winky unlike mosley who's **** was pushed in back to back.

 

your just making excuses now.

what was tito's best non-controversial win... mayorga? vargas? please

 

Still waiting for some one to please tell me who Mosley fought at 135?

 

about 7 successful title defenses there, i think