Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

My scorecard for Pacman vs JMM

1. 10-6 pac
2. 10-9 pac
3. 10-9 jmm
4. 10-9 jmm
5. 10-9 jmm
6. 10-9 jmm
7. 10-9 jmm
8. 10-9 jmm
9. 10-9 pac
10. 10-9 pac
11. 10-9 Jmm
12. 10-9 pac

113 -113 draw

Great comeback by Marquez in the middle rounds think he ran out of gas late on. Pac had hadnt been able to hit him with the left down the middle after the 2nd round but from round 9 Pac was landing it with more regularity.

I went for pac in 9th round 'cause he landed the harder shots and was pressing the fights he landed some realy good lefts that forces JMM back

 

Pacquaio: 1,2,9,10
Marquez: 3,4,5,6,7,8,11,12 ..............KD'D 1 x 3
Total: 113-112 Marquez

 

ill score this 2morow

 

Marquez/Pacquiao 2004

10-6 Pacquiao
10-9 Pacquiao
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Pacquiao
10-9 Marquez
10-9 Marquez

114-111 Marquez

9 was a close round but still think JMM edged it, the same way i scored it the night of the fight and havent changed my opinion after several viewings since, JMM won both their fights for me.

 

am i the only one who though JMM won the 2nd ?

 

the 2nd round was close

the 2nd fight was a JMM win

 

i was on about the 2nd round i thought it would be split but everyone is going with pac.

And yes i had him winning the 2nd fight too

 

the 2nd round was close i might rewatch it

the 2nd fight was clearer IMO

 

Pacquaio- Marquez
1. 10-6
2. 10-9
3. 9-10
4. 9-10
5. 9-10
6. 9-10
7. 10-9
8. 9-10
9.10-10
10.10-9
11.9-10
12.9-10

113-113

Its the 9th round that i`m still undecided about; on the first viewing i had it 10-9 pac which makes him 113-112 winner, on the 2nd viewing i had the round a draw.... leaning towards Marquez! Just such a close round

I will watch it again tomorrow fresh and see what score i give round 9

anyway, Marquez showed himself to be the superior fighter that night; outboxed Manny basically all fight

what the new an improved Pacquaio can do (or not do) to Marquez is something i would love to see more than any other fight....

 

it was a close round alright, the more i watch it the more i lean towards a Marquez round

 

Marquez wins this easy, after the 3rd round Marquez totally schools Manny. It has to at least a Marquez win by 2 or 3 points .. When the results came in for this i was shaking my head at 'boxing corruption' again .. How anybody can score this for Pac is a joke ..

 

Any chance of another?

 

tffp do your thing.

 

How about Witter-Kotelnik??? Seen a lot of people saying Kotelnik was robbed e.t.c, I remember having it close for Witter, wouldnt mind seeing it again.

 

please no witter.