Overrated / Underrated / Even

- for overrated
+ for underrated
= for even
/ for unknown (you dont know enough to rate them)

Rate these guys as they are upon this threads creation (August 5th 2009)

Floyd Mayweather Jr
Manny Pacquaio
Miguel Cotto
Juan Manuel Marquez
Paul Williams
Kelly Pavlik
Shane Mosley
Andre Berto
Wladamir Klitshko
Vitali Klitshko
David Haye
Chad Dawson
Roy Jones Jr
Lucian Bute
Allan Green
Sergie Dzinzurik
Joshua Clottey
Amir Kahn
Edwin Valero
Ali Funeka
Joan Guzman
Christobal Arreola
Mikkel Kessler
Andre Ward
Andre Dirrell
Carl Froch
Arthur Abraham
Nate Campbell
Tim Bradley

 

a lot of these guys i cant even properly evaluate

 

Dam u dont even have the fighter listed dat i luv 2 critisize

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr =
Manny Pacquaio =
Miguel Cotto = (maybe a little overrated at times, but i don't have the heart to put that)
Juan Manuel Marquez =
Paul Williams +
Kelly Pavlik =
Shane Mosley =
Andre Berto =
Wladamir Klitshko +
Vitali Klitshko = (i think sometimes people overstate the gap between Wlad and Vitali)
David Haye -
Chad Dawson = (under appreciated in terms of popularity)
Roy Jones Jr =
Lucian Bute +
Allan Green -
Sergie Dzinzurik =
Joshua Clottey = (his defensive ability gets overrated a bit however)
Amir Kahn =
Edwin Valero -
Ali Funeka =
Joan Guzman +
Christobal Arreola -
Mikkel Kessler =
Andre Ward =
Andre Dirrell - (until he proves himself at all)
Carl Froch =
Arthur Abraham = (maybe overrated slightly, he is inconsistent)
Nate Campbell =
Tim Bradley +

A quick list, its a hard thing to do because every fighter is both hated and loved, underrated and overrated.

 

I feel like i put everyone on there... who'd i miss?

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr =
Manny Pacquaio +
Miguel Cotto +
Juan Manuel Marquez +
Paul Williams =
Kelly Pavlik -
Shane Mosley-
Andre Berto =
Wladamir Klitshko +
Vitali Klitshko =
David Haye -
Chad Dawson -
Roy Jones Jr -
Lucian Bute -
Allan Green -
Sergie Dzinzurik +
Joshua Clottey +
Amir Kahn -
Edwin Valero +
Ali Funeka -
Joan Guzman +
Christobal Arreola -
Mikkel Kessler -
Andre Ward -
Andre Dirrell +
Carl Froch -
Arthur Abraham +
Nate Campbell -
Tim Bradley =

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr /
Manny Pacquaio -
Miguel Cotto /
Juan Manuel Marquez /
Paul Williams /
Kelly Pavlik /
Shane Mosley /
Andre Berto /
Wladamir Klitshko /
Vitali Klitshko /
David Haye /
Chad Dawson /
Roy Jones Jr /
Lucian Bute /
Allan Green /
Sergie Dzinzurik /
Joshua Clottey /
Amir Kahn /
Edwin Valero +
Ali Funeka /
Joan Guzman /
Christobal Arreola /
Mikkel Kessler /
Andre Ward /
Andre Dirrell /
Carl Froch /
Arthur Abraham /
Nate Campbell /
Tim Bradley /

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr +
Manny Pacquaio =
Miguel Cotto +
Juan Manuel Marquez +
Paul Williams =
Kelly Pavlik +
Shane Mosley -
Andre Berto +
Wladamir Klitshko -
Vitali Klitshko =
David Haye =
Chad Dawson =
Roy Jones Jr =
Lucian Bute =
Allan Green =
Sergie Dzinzurik +++
Joshua Clottey +
Amir Kahn -
Edwin Valero =
Ali Funeka +
Joan Guzman =
Christobal Arreola =
Mikkel Kessler =
Andre Ward =
Andre Dirrell -
Carl Froch -
Arthur Abraham =
Nate Campbell -
Tim Bradley =


Hard to judge most of them cause alot of people have alot of different opinions of them.

 

Where your ratings walk?

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr =
Manny Pacquaio =
Miguel Cotto +
Juan Manuel Marquez =
Paul Williams =
Kelly Pavlik -
Shane Mosley =
Andre Berto +
Wladamir Klitshko +
Vitali Klitshko +
David Haye -
Chad Dawson /
Roy Jones Jr =
Lucian Bute /
Allan Green /
Sergie Dzinzuri /
Joshua Clottey =
Amir Kahn =
Edwin Valero -
Ali Funeka /
Joan Guzman -
Christobal Arreola -
Mikkel Kessler -
Andre Ward -
Andre Dirrell =
Carl Froch -
Arthur Abraham =
Nate Campbell =
Tim Bradley +

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr =
Manny Pacquiao =
Miguel Cotto =
Juan Manuel Marquez =
Paul Williams +
Kelly Pavlik +
Shane Mosley =
Andre Berto =
Wladamir Klitshko +
Vitali Klitshko +
David Haye -
Chad Dawson =
Roy Jones Jr =
Lucian Bute +
Allan Green =
Sergie Dzinzurik =
Joshua Clottey =
Amir Kahn -
Edwin Valero -
Ali Funeka -
Joan Guzman +
Christobal Arreola -
Mikkel Kessler +
Andre Ward =
Andre Dirrell =
Carl Froch =
Arthur Abraham +
Nate Campbell +
Tim Bradley =

 

+


That's mine!!

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr -
Manny Pacquaio =
Miguel Cotto =
Juan Manuel Marquez=
Paul Williams -
Kelly Pavlik =
Shane Mosley =
Andre Berto /
Wladamir Klitshko +
Vitali Klitshko =
David Haye -
Chad Dawson -
Roy Jones Jr=
Lucian Bute +
Allan Green /
Sergie Dzinzurik =
Joshua Clottey =
Amir Kahn -
Edwin Valero -
Ali Funeka /
Joan Guzman =
Christobal Arreola =
Mikkel Kessler =
Andre Ward =
Andre Dirrell /
Carl Froch -
Arthur Abraham=
Nate Campbell =
Tim Bradley =

 

cant be arsed.