Who's a better all round fighter, Pacquao or Calzaghe?

The red is to answer some idiotic questions you have, Pacquiao is not undefeated, Joe is, and guess what? Joe never demanded someone come down in weight in the contract its always been a straight up fight.... you make the limit and so will I

Why is it Manny has to have these legal loop holes regarding weight? are they that insecure? of course they are... Freddy knows what weight loss will do to ya... this is why he is doing it....:hi:

 

OMG, knocked down thrice and still JMM can't adapt?

it's hard for a boxer to fight at a high competitive level if he had to jump 2 divisons higher at that age. i'm not saying that a younger version @ 130lbs of jmm would beat pbf, but i'm sure it would have been more competitive.

 

Not it would not have been more competitive, you have two counter punchers the better one will win, thats Mayweather :bbb

 

well to be fair, he said p4p. it means that hypothetically, "if they were the same size", pac would KO him. i don't see anything wrong with that. taking away Ike's size advantage over pac means pac will have more punsh resistance in this situation. but if he said "this version of pac will beat prime Ike", then that is a whole different story.

 

NEITHER!!!!!!!!!!!

Both are Bums.

Fight the best of the best when they are on top of their game not at the end of their careers.

 

Look at your avatar.

 

You cant say Pac has taken the bigger challenges when he and roach demand welters come down lower in weight...:nono

 

And your point!!!!!!

I rock my avatar proudly b/c he's a fukin BEAST. Everybody is running from him. He'll be the future P4P

 

there you see an example of someone fighting a guy on the end of his career.

 

Who's Calzaghe?

 

You can't find two people out of 300 million in the US who could answer that. Joe is a complete nobody.



Pac took on greater and greater challenges and moved up multiple weight classes.

Joe fought bums, struggled with average guys, then tacked two ancient ATGs (and got dropped by both) onto his resume at the end and ran for the hills.

Compare Joe to Ottke not Pac (and this is from one who has watched every round of Joe's career).

 

Though I praise Calzaghe for his accomplishments... I still can't respect his style... he throws like a sub-novice amateur...

 

what matters is that he gets things done

 

First off know your boxing info. That was the only fight Paul the punisher williams could get at that time. Due to the fact of what i stated in some of my previous post. Paul williams is a the most FEARED man in boxing. Look at the ghost. He knew he was going to get his ass wooped. soon to be P4P best.

 

All that BS doesnt change what i said,he fought a guy (Winky)that is on the end of his career.