I voted Margarito. Winky was coming off of a very long period of inactivity and he lost to quintana in the first bout, although i feel it was a lackluster performance that he made up the in the rematch. Margarito was at the time considered the most feared man in boxing p4p and for paul to go in there and take it to him showed alot.
I'm with you, its Margarito Although Quintana KO1 was a good win, especially since he was avenging a defeat. However at the end of the day Quintana is just not a high-level fighter.
Winky. Margarito is nothing without his special gloves. And the other guy is noone period. That leaves Winky, who still after a break in an awesome name on Paul's resume.
For me, PW's win against AM was his best. Williams was the underdog in that fight and he beat Margarito for the WW title.
Winky has to be his best win, He dominated and the fight was turned into an exhibition. It became the PW showcase. (+ His first major win @ a higher weight class) The Margarito fight, Tho a great win was still a close fight regardless how people try to twist it.
Easily against Margarito. Williams was the underdog in that fight and people keep saying ( Williams lucky it's not a 15 rounds fight.) Well after Margarito stunned Williams in the 11th round, Williams close the show in a great faction in the 12th.
Marg...Winky was shot and hand'nt been in the ring in 2 years, i give him little credit for that win Quintana was a pretty good win though, but Marg was better
they are all good for diff reasons am- showed grit and beat the supposed most feared guy cq- avenged a loss emphatically winky- blew him out like nobody has done before... nobody from 154-160 could have blown him out like that