BBC p4p British rankings published..........

what about Paul McCloskey?? Would he make it onto the list?

 

No Rhodes or Macklin? I've seen worse though. (Kos.... )

 

suprised Murray, Monroe and Witter were on the list.

I'd have Khan above Hatton too.

 

You can't say anything about bad lists!

 

Your right :good I completely forgot about him. Maybe not 10, but he would be very close to it for sure.

 

I don't hate Khan.

If your going to do a P4P it has to be surely based on recent results and performances relative to the level of competition.

-Hatton beat Lazcano, no.1 LWW contender Malinaggi then lost to the P4P best fighter in the world


-Khan lost to a journeyman (even worse then Hatton lost to Pacman) beat Oisin ***an (not even worth mentioning), got a shitty win over Barrera and beat 2nd class champ in Kotelnik.


Compare the two and I think youd be mildly insane to have Khan up. Besides Hattons win over PM was more convincing then any of Khans.

 

Kell is way too high. Has he beat a live body yet?

 

I suppose I would say -

1 Haye
2 Froch
3 Hatton
4 Khan
5 Munroe
6 Brook
7 Cleverley
8 Rhodes
9 McCloskey
10 Murray

 

No love for Macklin Greg?