Wins over Judah

Only one judge gave Judah 4 rounds. And Judah didn't win 4 of the first 6.

 

He took the easy way out of the clottey and mayweather fights.

 

Cotto beat the **** outta him. Floyd just beat him.

 

Cotto/Judah was like Ali/Holmes. Judah barely lifted his gloves after the em... "Early round fouls."

 

Co-sign.

 

Mayweather because Floyd had an injured right hand going into the fight

 

well thats why people feel cotto was a better win I understand Zab was mopping the Floor with Cotto. But Cotto won

 

How about Kostya Tszyu? He blasted Judah out in two rounds.

 

Clottey split judah open with that great left uppercut and he did it in less rounds than mayweather or cotto and i believe clottey gave judah the worst beating.

 

PBF fought a prime Judah and came from behind to win.

 

Tszyu. But from that list I gotta say Floyd, hands down.

 

I'd have to disagree with that. The only fighter to really beat a prime Judah was Tszyu and though he looked bad at times he ko'd him. Overall I'd have to agree Tszyu had a better win over Judah because he beat a prime Judah but since he's not on this list the vote that I gave went to Floyd.

 

FMJ easily
Clottey win was ok
Cotto went low after getting his ass kicked

 

So is it the best win or the most dominating win?


If you say "best" it would have to be Floyd, because he was closer to prime.
If you say "most dominating" then it would have to be Clottey, as he was never in trouble.

 

Mayweather's win was best. He fought the fresher Judah and didn't have to bust him on the balls to turn the fight around, though he got his balls busted.