You are either not serious or definitely do not understand the meaning of P4P. I currently bet on the second. George Foreman in an all time P4P top10 list ? His sole P4P proving fight was against Gerry Cooney. And then you have his fights against Ali and even worse actually : Jimmy Young. A young Foreman went down in this one against a supposedly feather fisted super defensive boxer without a good reason/excuse (give me one if you have). I think Reggie Johnson , Jorge Castro , James Toney , Marlon Starling , Aaron Davis , Ike Quartery , Jose Luis Lopez and Shane Mosley deserve more. Neither was as dominant , but then , they (maybe except Davis) did not enjoy the huge average size advantage Foreman had over his best opponents.
You got it even wronger . Hearns ? the only reason I can see for putting him in such a list is his multiple alphabet titles at 5 weights. (6 if you count the IBO with a win even I respect over a tougher , younger , bigger and dangerous Nate Miller) Louis ? no. You'd better bring back Foreman. Ali ? no , and definitely not that high. Try this (I just think of it at this moment) : 1. Sam Langford 2. Henry Armstrong 3. Mike Tyson 4. James Toney 5. Roberto Duran 6. Julio Cesar Chavez 7. Hector Camacho 8. Mike McCallum 9. Marlon Starling 10. David Tua And it may change. Very hard.
What could be funnier than David Tua at #10 all time pound for pound?! By the way, what heightdo you think Tua is?
List your list and I will tell you . I answered it where you asked it. What height do you think he is ?
Well i'd say that Sugar Ray Leoanrd would be favoured (he doesn't make your list?). You can add Kid Gavilan, Charley Burley, Sugar Ray Robinson and maybe Mickey Walker. These men, I would favour over Hearns. But then I think this weight is not his best. He has the experience againt Leonard and i not fighting the weight so much at 154. I think he is best there.