Ring Mag's Pond for Pound mistake

Shane is at 10 or 11, not above Marquez brothers or Hatton.

 

So you think Shane should be above JMM? Thanks for the laugh.

 

Yeah, yeah, we'll see.

 

He's #13 on their top 100 in the January 2008 issue.

 

You might want to edit the title..

 

Okay who the **** has Shane beat in recent times that is more significant/impressive than Hatton's wins over Tszyu and Castillo, or Marquez's over Barrera and Juarez, or Rafa Marquez's over Vazquez, or Cotto's over Judah, Urkal etc. Sure He may be a better fighter even at this stage than most of these guys, but to become top 10 you have to beat the best fighters. Collazo is good, no better, a shot Vargas times 2 is again a couple of good wins, but not enough to make you top 10. Anyway quit moaning, he is only 11 or 12 anyway and we will see whether he belongs above Cotto on Saturday.

 

At the moment, JMM, Rafa, and Hatton deserve to be above Mosley

 

Shane is one of my favorites and I agree with this.

The winner of Cotto - Mosley is top 10.

 

I find the pound for pound BS a boring. It is all speculation anyway.

 

The funniest contradiction with the P4P list is when a fighter is dropped, simply for losing to another fighter who was already ranked higher then them on the P4P list. Example, if Hatton loses to Mayweather, he will most likely be dropped a few spots or off completely......WHY? According to the list anybody Floyds size or smaller SHOULD and is EXPECTED to lose, so why shouldn't Hatton stay where he is?

 

I am actually pretty comfortable with the p4p list.

 

I stopped giving a **** about P4P rankings about 2 or 3 years ago.

 

After Shane beats Cotto, you may have a point. But until then, hatton can be rightfully ranked above him.

 

p4p fighters in the ring are to much about what they did a few years ago and do not take into consideration how they have faded or would fare against younger fighters in the divisions they currently campaign at.

i think the rankings should be more fluid,and be more, what have you done for me latley, with young turk`s being given a chance , instead of waiting for the dethroning or 1 fight against a relative non entity and they are right back in there.