ring magazine jr welter ratings

Except the ratings aren't based on who might beat who. They're based on who have you beaten and who have you beaten lately?

 

Even beating an old Nate Cambell is better than anything Mccloskey has. Hell even ancient Antonio Diaz is better than most of Mccloskeys opponents.

 

Ortiz should be on there, he just beat campbell, come on now..

 

McCloskey V Malignaggi - who wins?

 

Its not like they didn't have the grounds to do so

 

id probably put kotelnik above maidana, this myth about him being a top 4 name is a myth, kotelnik has done more and fought better and should be seen as one of the best especially since the beating he put on alexander.

urango and paulie, unsure if they are still top 10 material

 

Kotelnik should be above Maidana. Ortiz should be top ten.

 

i reckon ortiz should be where urango is.

is urango still top 10 now? i know he is a 2 time champ but i honestly dont see him as top 10 material no more

 

so Pac vacated the title then.