1.Mayweather 2.Pacquaio 3.martinez 4.Bradley 5.Juan Manual Marquez 6.W Klitschko 7.Hopkins 8.Berto 9.Khan 10.Gamboa surpised to not see Berto or Gamboa in many peoples choice :yikes Donaire and Montiel just dont cut it for me to be honest :-(
come on man, check montiel's ( or Wonjongkam's ) resume and compare it with Gamboa's Berto's or Khan's !!! Or are HBO and Showtime fights the only one that counts to you?
I disagree with about 50% of these. Adamek is nowhere near top 15, Wlad has done nothing to earn top 5 either. You should at least beat somebody in the top 20 first.
i dont think you can take Floyd off the list but moving him down i can see. My only thing with moving him down is that if him and Pac do fight....does he get #1? Jumping whom ever you have in front of him.
Lol.. definitely dawg.. send me a message once you put up the thread!!.. Although I think I've seen your top 50
I think people should give him until May... that willa t least give him an entire year.. nobody took Mosley out their rankings when he was inactive longer.. or Winky Wright.. but I honestly think Mayweather will be done for good....
I like a few of the consensus lists, but does Ward have the cv yet to be that high? He seems lower top ten in a few of the lists, but seems to me to be getting too much credit for still having his 0. He was great against Kessler, but that is just one fight. His style is criticized by many. I do think that he will get solidly into the top ten, might even get to the top of the tree, but he needs a couple more fights like the Kessler fight, to me. As a fighter at this point I would rather have Froch's cv than Ward's, yet Froch is top 15 or not in the list at all for many posters. I think that we are in danger of giving Ward too much credit for potential (which don't get me wrong I think he has buckets of!).
1.Hugh Necks 2.Hugh Necks 3.Hugh Necks 4.Hugh Necks 5.Hugh Necks 6.Hugh Necks 7.Hugh Necks 8.Hugh Necks 9.Hugh Necks 10.Hugh Necks 11.Hugh Necks 12.Hugh Necks 13.Hugh Necks 14.Hugh Necks 15.Hugh Necks
Pot calling kettle black springs to mind. He is Herbzg and he is the most knowledgeable and insightful poster on ESB. Deal with it. :deal
1. Pacquiao 2. JMM 3. Martinez 4. Wlad Klitschko 5. Hopkins 6. Bradley 7. Donaire 8. Montiel 9. Ward 10. Cotto 11. Vitali Klitschko 12. Lopez 13. Khan 14. Wonjongkam 15. Froch
Nice list, but what about this power puncher? http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_id=514537&cat=boxer
