Out of these, who was/is the biggest cherry picker?

Of the 40+ who voted for Floyd. I just have to laugh because if you ask them to list their top 5 p4p.

Guess where Mayweather is?

 

A guy can avoid the toughest challenges and still himself be a great fighter.

 

P4P is based on accomplishments, no one uses it as a head to head match up anymore.

 

cherrypicker=calzaghe
shameless ducker=floyd

 

this is incorrect. it was Floyd who said Cotto was too green. I can't remember which fight, but in a post fight interview, merchant asked floyd if he would fight cotto and floyd said cotto was too green. no one in cotto's side ever said that.

 

Floyd was with Arum at that time. Arum and Floyd both said it.

 

it IS rjj...

& anyone who disagrees either doesn't understand the phrase "cherrypicker" or hasn't been following boxing longer than 5 minutes.

 

good one man. atsch

 

Pac, Calzaghe. Mayweather's only cherry pick was Marquez coming off a 2 year layoff.

 

The ONLY way you could try to make a case for Mayweather is if you are talking ratio to their talent, in which case you would be acknowledging that Mayweather is greater than the other choices. His W/L weighted with his opposition is among the best in boxing history, as an undefeated 3 year Ring P4P #1. (no, I don't rank Mayweather in my top 20 all time)

This site is straight ridiculous half the time...

 

you're right about that.
but don't fall into the trap of defending him because of his 'titles' - that's what calzaghe fans do because they ahve nowhere else to go.

floyd still played the same game calzaghe did, but he did it on the world stage so he couldn't bull**** fight-starved brits.

but he's still guilty

 

I love RJJ...he was my favorite fighter for a long time, but he did consecutively fight a lot of bums

 

interesting list of those that voted for Calzaghe :think

 

it's not them you're highlighting..it's you.

get a girlfriend..it won't matter after that

 

does your wife count?