Is it possible that Calzaghe is overhyped because BOTH Lacy and Kessler were?

Why continue to pick apart the career of professional boxers? In the end does it really even mean anything? Calzaghe has never lost a fight in his ridiculously long career, and hes only lost a hand full of ROUNDS on top of that. Don't crucify a man for fighting in a division that lacks superstar talent, all Calzaghe is doing is milking the 168lb division for as long as he wants. And then hes going to retire with a smile on his face. And thats how the story of Joe Calzaghe will go.

 

Calzaghe has outclassed all.

It would be a huge conincidence if somehow everyone he fought was rubbish.

The is a 0.0376% chance Joe Calzaghe isn't the best boxer of all time.

 

Overhyped? WTF? The guy's been around for a decade and has only been noticed in the last couple of years.

 

Unifying is a division is quite an admirable feat. He might be hyped up, but we are not going to know if he does not get beaten, which seems unlikely to happen. As far as I can tell, he is clearly the best in the 160-175 divisions.

 

Lacy is **** now and may never become good again, but he was steamrolling good fighters before he fought Calzaghe. Calzaghe ruined Lacy, he was not **** all along. Also Kessler was a proven A grade fighter, he hammered Mundine and Beyer, showing great power and skills in doing so, and I have no doubt he will have a great career ahead of him that will prove how good a win he was for Calzaghe.

 

This content is protected

 

It is possible, but I don't think that Kessler was overrated. Lacy was overrated (because of his exposure in the US and his muscular Tysonisque physique but to dominate him the way JC did was a great feat.

 

Was Lacy overrated or has Joe destroyed him as a fighter?Calzaghe is in a catch 22 whoever he faces some people will say they were ,old,overrated,to small or just bums in the first place.He can't win in some peoples eyes and if someone does beat him,they will say hes been exposed as a bum.

 

Pemberton and Reid were both Manfredo level when Lacy fought them and Lacy absolutely dominated both of them, i think its fairly obvious Lacy isnt the fighter he was pre-Calzaghe, i do think he was over-hyped slightly though. Nevetheless, Lacy was a top 3 SMW at the time along with Kessler and Calzaghe. Watch Kessler fight, does he honestly look overrated? Dawson is the only other man between 160-175 that would beat Kessler IMO.

 

when a fighter outclasses every opponent that hes faced your always going to get the "overrated ****"....It's annoying to tell you the truth. Calzaghe dominates all. He doesn't just win, he wins every round every fight is a clinic.

 

lmfaooooo

Thats cus he beat Antonio Tarver and thats the last 175lb fighter he ever wants to fight.

 

We can pick aprt both fighters resumes ! What diffrence does it make when they meet ?