Rank Winky, Oscar, Tito, and Mosley in order of ATG....

Love this thread, this is a great example that ATG list are all subjective and bias by whoever is making them. Just like P4P lists people will never agree on them and you can easily make cases for different fighters. And that's the case for any ATG list from 1 to 100

:hat

 

Didnt DLH feed on tito's left overs after they fought eachother???? wtf?!?! He didnt even last that long against BHOP...

 

You consider BHop at the time of the DLH fight to have been among Trinidad's leftovers?

 

You misunderstood...DLH fought BHOP/VARGAS/MAYORGA after Tito did and didnt do better

 

He did much better against Mayorga and Vargas you clown. As he did against Carr too. Oscar also managed to win some rounds against Hopkins too, whereas Tito just won the award for Grant glove eating.

 

He didn't?

Had Hopkins landed a similar liver shot on Trinidad, what do you think would have happened? :think

It could just as easily instead be the legend of Tito shitting his pants. :good

 

Oscar


Shane
Tito
Winky

Shane, Winky and Tito are all interchangeable. Oscar is top by miles.

 

GTFO!!! that **** looked like a love pat at least tito lasted till the 12...Vargas was all roided up against him and mayorga got DESTROYED by Tito... i guess i shouldnt assume that the beatings tito gave them dint have an effect on them...ass clowns

 

This content is protected

Oscar just operates at a higher technical level, thats why he was able to start to run away against Vargas as the fight rolled on, and didn' have the same trouble Tito had with the awkward Mayorga. Knocking them both out in the process.

Just out of interest how did Tito do against Ike Quartey when he fought him during Tito's own 7 year title reign at 147?

 

what did quartey accomplish after the loss???

 

Trinidad- of all of them, he in his prime at his natural weight was the best

Oscar
Winky
Mosley

 

Why didn't Tito fight Quartey in the seven years he was champion when Quartey held wins over Carr and Phillips? It only took Oscar just over two years to fight Quartey after his move up to 147.

How come it took Tito nearly five years and a loss to de la Hoya to get Whitaker in the ring? When Oscar decided to take on Whitaker as his first 147 fight.

I'll leave it there, I'm off to watch Wall Street.

 

A love pat.

Ever taken a liver punch? :deal

 

how can oscar be top,when did he beat any of those guys.the others fought each other.oscar fought them and lost.rate oscar top an ur an idiot