If all decisions went the way you scored it, what would ATG's records look like?

We all know Holmes got the crap beat out of him and thus had zero chance of winning.

 

Oscar De La Hoya(no ATG, but have to post what his record ought to be) -

34-8-1

Scored the Trinidad fight a draw. Scored Whitaker and Quartey for them, scored Sturm for Sturm.

 

:yikes

 

Oscar De La Hoya: 38-4-1.
Losing to Whitaker, Sturm and drawing with Quartey. Winning against Tito, Mayweather and the rematch with Shane.

Pernell Whitaker: 42-2-1-1(NC).
Beating Ramirez in the first fight, Chavez and DLH. Drawing the first fight with Rivera.

Fighting Harada: 57-5
Beating Kingpetch in the rematch and beating Famechon in their first encounter

Winky Wright: 53-2-2
Beating Taylor, Simon and drawing with Hopkins and Vargas.

Marvin Hagler: 64-2-1
Beating Leonard and Antuofermo in the first fight.

Floyd Mayweather: 37-2
Losing to Castillo in their first fight and DLH

James Toney: 70-6-3-1(NC) (stays the same)
Losing to McCallum in the 2nd bout, Tiberi, Rahman and drawing with Johnson and Griffin in their first bout. Beating McCallum in their first bout, Griffin in the rematch and Peter in the first fight.

Jose Luis Castillo: 56-9
Beating Mayweather in their first fight and losing twice to Stevie Johnston.

Jose Luis Ramirez: 103-8
Beating Rosario in their first fight and Arguello, and losing to Whitaker in their first fight.

One guy I'll do a bit later on is Eusebio Pedroza. He's had plenty of controversial bouts.

Oh and I'd just like to say, Castillo, Ramirez, Toney and Wright probably aren't ATGs, but I chucked em in anyway.

 

Only problems I have.

 

My most "out there" card, I admit.

 

They do if the opponent plods on after ya, too poor on the night to get any decent shots off.

 

If I can fix 1 or 2 bad calls

Lewis Holyfiled 1 will be the first on my list.
Though Douglas won by ko, I still dont see why they had Tyson ahead??
I will give Robinson the 3rd Fullmer fight. The series end at a even 2-2 instand of the 2-1-1.
I change the Siki McTige points verdict. I felt Siki should have won.
I will indeed change the Louis Walcott 1 fight to a win for Walcott.
most of the 90's 2000's bad calls like DLH Tito, DLH Mosely 2, DLH Sweet Pea, and one or 2 of Chavez fights like that draw with Whitaker .

 

When 90% of the people think it is, then it's the other dolts that have to examine themselves and their scoring of a fight. If you're in that category then, hey, welcome to Club Bill. :good

 

SS, I dont see DLH wining the Mayweather fight, I felt Floyd won pretty sqaure and fair, the cards were WAY closer than the fight relly was.

 

I think you'd find more that had Oscar ahead than had Peanut Head beating Spinks (fight I). However, if that's barely one in ten then it doesn't matter. No controversy. End of chat. :good

 

Erik Morales 51-3-0 and a titlist in 4 divisions.

 

Winning which fights other than the Diaz fight, and losing which fights?

 

morales lost twice to pac, and he lost the series against barrera, he defeintly lost to that other guy in 2005. I dont see this 51-3 record, unless ur a hardcore morales fan.

 

I think you are well within your right to say Mayweather won the fight and I'd accept anything up to about a 2 or 3 point win for Mayweather as being feasible, as quite a few rounds were close, but for all the guys that bring out scoecards like 9-3 Mayweather, I say NO WAY.